I find it a bit UP, it's cost is too high, maybe lower it to 5 or 6. But I think that you guys are looking at it the wrong way. I think it also has incredible potential as an almost one hit KO creature control (I guess that's why it deals extra damage for the upgraded one). It's a permanent control AND creature control card at the same time, albeit not a very good permanent control card. It's 8 death for a one turn delay one hit KO for any non-Armagio, Massive Dragon, Chimera or Voodoo Doll.