Forced Choice | Forced Choice

[TheAccuso]

Name changed, switching effect reduced to 1, cost changed.

[OdinVanguard]

I like it. A more subtle version of card advantage than pure draw power. I think it would make a nice addition to time's arsenal

[TheAccuso]

I like it. A more subtle version of card advantage than pure draw power. I think it would make a nice addition to time's arsenal

Ty odin, i apprecieted.

[Annele]

CURATOR COMMENT

This card will not be permitted into the Crucible due to one or more of the following errors:

• Table filled out incorrectly.

Correct these errors as soon as possible and feel free to submit again when ready.

Thank you. ^_^

Make sure to remember that the "Element" row is only to be filled in with the written element, in this case "Time", not the quanta graphic.
Also, please make sure to use the quanta graphic in the "Cost" section though, unless the card costs random quanta.
Thanks.

[OldTrees]

Element = Time not  (Time quanta)
Cost = 2 not 2 (2 )

Card Filtering is valuable but usually more valuable if repeatable. Currently this would be used primarily to keep the game in stasis (Like Silence and Nightmare) rather than act as card filtering.

[TheAccuso]

Element = Time not  (Time quanta)
Cost = 2 not 2 (2 )

Card Filtering is valuable but usually more valuable if repeatable. Currently this would be used primarily to keep the game in stasis (Like Silence and Nightmare) rather than act as card filtering.

I agree that the primarly use of this will be to do a little stall, is that bad?
Also time got draw power so you can actually manage to use it to get out some combo or even just creatures.

TY for the feedback.

[TheAccuso]

Fixed.

[OldTrees]

Element = Time not  (Time quanta)
Cost = 2 not 2 (2 )

Card Filtering is valuable but usually more valuable if repeatable. Currently this would be used primarily to keep the game in stasis (Like Silence and Nightmare) rather than act as card filtering.

I agree that the primarly use of this will be to do a little stall, is that bad?
Also time got draw power so you can actually manage to use it to get out some combo or even just creatures.

TY for the feedback.

If the card filtering was not the goal of the card, then why does it have card filtering?
If card filtering is the goal of the card then it needs to be made the primary usage.

[TheAccuso]

If the card filtering was not the goal of the card, then why does it have card filtering?
If card filtering is the goal of the card then it needs to be made the primary usage.

I'm sorry OT but i really don't get your criticism here.
The idea is to give elements with draw power an advantage over those who haven't and this is what this mechaninc does.
Note that you can fuel this also jsut with the mark and/or novas, so didn't have any element hate.

[OldTrees]

If the card filtering was not the goal of the card, then why does it have card filtering?
If card filtering is the goal of the card then it needs to be made the primary usage.

I'm sorry OT but i really don't get your criticism here.
The idea is to give elements with draw power an advantage over those who haven't and this is what this mechaninc does.
Note that you can fuel this also jsut with the mark and/or novas, so didn't have any element hate.

There are 2 parts to this card. One part prevents natural drawing. The other part returns a card to the deck and replaces that card with a new card. The first part is the stasis based  denial. The second part is called card filtering. Card filtering, as a mechanic, can be supported more or less ideally by the card it is on. This is a very suboptimal support for the card filtering effect relative to the alternatives.

So the question becomes which effect is primary and which can be modified?

[TheAccuso]

If the card filtering was not the goal of the card, then why does it have card filtering?
If card filtering is the goal of the card then it needs to be made the primary usage.

I'm sorry OT but i really don't get your criticism here.
The idea is to give elements with draw power an advantage over those who haven't and this is what this mechaninc does.
Note that you can fuel this also jsut with the mark and/or novas, so didn't have any element hate.

There are 2 parts to this card. One part prevents natural drawing. The other part returns a card to the deck and replaces that card with a new card. The first part is the stasis based  denial. The second part is called card filtering. Card filtering, as a mechanic, can be supported more or less ideally by the card it is on. This is a very suboptimal support for the card filtering effect relative to the alternatives.

So the question becomes which effect is primary and which can be modified?

I think that the primary effect is to give advantage to decks with draw power, so i suppose that the card filtering can be modified, but i don't see a problem in combining both in one card.
Do you have any specific suggestion?

[OldTrees]

If the card filtering was not the goal of the card, then why does it have card filtering?
If card filtering is the goal of the card then it needs to be made the primary usage.

I'm sorry OT but i really don't get your criticism here.
The idea is to give elements with draw power an advantage over those who haven't and this is what this mechaninc does.
Note that you can fuel this also jsut with the mark and/or novas, so didn't have any element hate.

There are 2 parts to this card. One part prevents natural drawing. The other part returns a card to the deck and replaces that card with a new card. The first part is the stasis based  denial. The second part is called card filtering. Card filtering, as a mechanic, can be supported more or less ideally by the card it is on. This is a very suboptimal support for the card filtering effect relative to the alternatives.

So the question becomes which effect is primary and which can be modified?

I think that the primary effect is to give advantage to decks with draw power, so i suppose that the card filtering can be modified, but i don't see a problem in combining both in one card.
Do you have any specific suggestion?

I would split this into 2 cards
1) Natural Draw Denial [The primary effect]
2) Card Filtering
This way you can give both effects the attention they demand. This is especially true for card filtering which currently is as hampered as an infected Anubis that starts with 2hp. (Card filtering usually comes into its own when it is repeatable.)