Earth Avatar | Gaea Avatar

[Ignion]

Alright, so what do you think the amount should be?

Unupped: + 10

Upped: + 15

More?

[YoYoBro]

I think the mechanic itself would be a bit wrong, as being able to sacrifice one's own pillars really depends on the kind of opponent and on the first draw etc. That would make the card situational.

[Ignion]

depends on the kind of opponent and on the first draw etc. That would make the card situational.

I see your point, but I also think that statement is true for many cards in this game? Bad draw = sucks. Some decks don't do well with particular decks.

I also think that this can be planned out if a user is going to use this card because one can have as many pillars as s/he wants.

Maybe I can up the amount of HP it gains, which will be well-worth a lost pillar? Any thoughts?

Here's another thought. I can go back to the original idea of using the amount of earth quanta. Then, I can modify it like this "gains the amount of earth quanta owned divided by 2 every turn."

[YoYoBro]

Then, back to my older suggestion, I'd say "gains 3 hp per 10 earth quanta in your possession per turn"

[Ignion]

Then, back to my older suggestion, I'd say "gains 3 hp per 10 earth quanta in your possession per turn"

I think that's way too weak?

[Ignion]

I decided to get more inputs on this, so I added a poll to this thread. Please vote 

[Ekki]

Then, back to my older suggestion, I'd say "gains 3 hp per 10 earth quanta in your possession per turn"

I think that's way too weak?

Making it "per turn" can be pretty neat, since it's a lot of growth if you have enough pillars

[Ignion]

Sorry if I confused some of you, but I took down my poll because I just had a really good idea to replace its skill. I think it's much better and adds more creativity to its strategy to not just the user but its opponents. I hope you like it!

[YoYoBro]

Cool. What about "2 hp for each earth creature including itself"? Most of these avatars would be mostly good for mono-color decks use anyway, so why not to tweak the effect so that it fits even more with earth's theme?

[Ignion]

I thought about it, but I was afraid it might be OP. But, you are right, I think it'll be ok after all. I'll change it 

[YoYoBro]

I think all avatars should be slightly more powerful when used within their elements' themes, but that's just my thought.

[Rutarete]

I think all avatars should be slightly more powerful when used within their elements' themes, but that's just my thought.

by themes, do you mean marks?