First off, that stick man is awesome!
Secondly, added a poll for cost, here is a breakdown of the version to help decide:
Creature Cost = Attack + HP + Ability Threat + Bonus
For the version 3 |3 Unupped
Attack: +1
HP: + 0 (1-5)
Ability Threat: +2 (Permanent PA in the Shield Slot)
Bonus: None.
Final Cost: 3:earth
Upped
Attack: +1
HP: + 0 (1-5)
Ability Threat: +3 (Permanent PA in the Weapon Slot)
Bonus: -1 for upgrade
Final Cost: 3:earth
For the version 3 |2 Unupped
Attack: +1
HP: + 0 (1-5)
Ability Threat: +2 (Permanent PA in the Shield Slot)
Bonus: None.
Final Cost: 3:earth
Upped
Attack: +1
HP: + 0 (1-5)
Ability Threat: +2 (Permanent PA in the Weapon Slot)
Bonus: -1 for upgrade
Final Cost: 2:earth
For the version 2 |2 Unupped
Attack: +1
HP: + 0 (1-5)
Ability Threat: +1 (Permanent PA in the Shield Slot)
Bonus: None.
Final Cost: 2:earth
Upped
Attack: +1
HP: + 0 (1-5)
Ability Threat: +2 (Permanent PA in the Weapon Slot)
Bonus: -1 for upgrade
Final Cost: 2:earth