Voting: Make This Card!

[vrt]

Winners are in!

The winner of the Make This Card contest is Kamietsu's Murky Water! Congratulations!

In a shared second place, we find the Eldritch Chandelier and Overflow. Well done, Essence and ftbhrygvn!





Here's what you need to keep in mind, though. The winning card should be:

1. Balanced.
2. Fun.
3. Not overpowered.
4. Original.

With that said; you've got a week to cast your votes! Here are the entries:




1. (http://www.screenshotdumpster.com/) (http://www.screenshotdumpster.com/)

2.

3.

4.

5.

6.

7.

8. (http://www.screenshotdumpster.com/) (http://www.screenshotdumpster.com/)

9.

10.

11.

12. (http://elementscommunity.org/forum/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=4192.0;attach=1039;image)(http://elementscommunity.org/forum/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=4192.0;attach=1040;image)

13. (http://elementscommunity.org/forum/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=4192.0;attach=1047;image)(http://elementscommunity.org/forum/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=4192.0;attach=1048;image)

14. (http://www.screenshotdumpster.com/)

15.

16.

17.

18. (http://www.screenshotdumpster.com/) (http://www.screenshotdumpster.com/)

19. (http://www.screenshotdumpster.com/view/m7Gbd54856/elements_card) (http://www.screenshotdumpster.com/view/m7Gbd54860/elements_card22)

20. (http://www.screenshotdumpster.com/) (http://www.screenshotdumpster.com/)

21. (http://elementscommunity.org/forum/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=4192.0;attach=1069;image)(http://elementscommunity.org/forum/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=4192.0;attach=1070;image)

22.

23.

24:

Also; please do post the reason you're voting - we're curious!

[standizzle]

number 20 - overflow.

why? because there is currently NOTHING currently in game that can counter a enchant artifact'd dissapation field.

this. does that. to a degree.

i WOULD have voted for fountain of forgetting, but no one in their right mind would play a card that discards their own hand/cards. if it was only opponant discards, and the cost to play it was like a 7 or 8. it would have had my vote.

but, i vote overflow because of this.

[Astaroth]

I voted for Feigned Fountain, Leaking Sewage, and Fountain of Renewal.

Feigned Fountain - I liked this card because I've been waiting for a card like it. "Recasting" the last ability or spell seems intriguing to me. Plus, the name fits perfectly. Feign means "to imitate or copy," and that's exactly what this fountain does. Although I believe that it should be destroyed after just two uses, I thought it deserved my vote.

Leaking Sewage - This card seemed balance, the name fit its effect, and it further helps the water/death synergy. Congeal + this card seems like a lot of fun. I especially liked the added "Legendary" status of the card, because it showed me that the creator tried to balance the card.

Fountain of Renewal - Who doesn't vote for their own card? If you didn't like it, then you wouldn't have created it.

[icybraker]

Preservation, all the way. It's choice number 1 and it will win the number 1 prize. Not overpowered either - we need a good stall in this game, especially since Sundial was nerfed.

And it's not that cheap, either - dual element. I think it's fair and it's my vote.

I also voted for Chandelier and Overflow.

[miniwally]

Only one to vote for 16.

I like the idea of sacrificing some of your health as this makes you use more thought behind whether to sue it or not.

[Antagon]

Only one to vote for 16.

I like the idea of sacrificing some of your health as this makes you use more thought behind whether to sue it or not.

yeah, i like

[Kamietsu]

It would be nice if my submission was in the voting.

[Angelic_Dawn]

Sorry to my previous vote for
8: Forgetting, Because it could be nifty im sure there is some nice trick possible with it.  (especialy If combined with 23:)
or if you run a deck with no tricks, and dont have any need to hold your cards, or an opponent that likes to play tricks.

I just liked Murky better
 


And now without further ado,
In no particular order these three should inmo form the winning list.


6: Brilliance
because its simple and elegant, and still has much potential.

23: Youth,
Think its more Balanced, if not just more fun, then Shard.
 (And can actualy form combinations and tricks, instead of just boringly adding 5 at every point (see 8:) , And it inspires tactics and counter play like holding in your hands to prevent healing if you got no destroy instead of just beeing unable to influence stuff)

24: Murky,
Very original concept, Not to strong, still usefull, And very flavourfull really fits the concept of the Darkness Element.



Edit:
Tho honerable mention to

1: Preservance,
think its very nice, but Disquilify it from winning as i think its a bit to strong. (Vrt Said: winning card must not be Op.)
OverPowered = Unkillable and undeckable in 1 card, Yes please.  but thats my oppinion

and
7:  Light,
Unlimited light producing Creatures for 6, But that 6 you'll get back asap +lots of intrest, Yes please (less Op. but still inmo  )

[vrt]

Sorry Kamietsu! I've added you, and for the next 10 minutes, anyone is free to change their vote as to give Kami's entry a fair chance, too.

[Wisemage]

i voted for overfill/overflow, because we really need a sacrifice option in this game.

[yaladilae]

Leaking Sewage - This card seemed balance, the name fit its effect, and it further helps the water/death synergy. Congeal + this card seems like a lot of fun. I especially liked the added "Legendary" status of the card, because it showed me that the creator tried to balance the card.

Thanks for voting for me

Now,if i could get more support 

[Kamietsu]

my votes: 10, 15, and 24

10 is a very good addition because it solves the problem if you fill up your field. Though it also makes malignant cell a little bit less useful.

15 because it's a good idea for healing. You can choose to play your card, heal yourself, or balance the two options.

24 because it's my card and also it's a nice way to bring down powerful creatures. It's good for animated titans if you can't get rid of them, you can bring their damage down to 1 pretty quickly. Same for large dragons.