Voting: Card Design Competition: Another Epic 3 Card Design Challenge!

[Daxx]

its mostly just a popularity contest.

That explains it. We all know you're awesome, KDZ.

[SunnyGreens]

its mostly just a popularity contest.

I hope that's not true, that would make these pointless.

[Deedle]

Wow I can't believe the amount of votes for number 3, with a card better than quintessence in  , and OP Ball Lightning generator that also buffs it sell,

[moomoose]

i wouldnt say anything you said is all that accurate.  liberty isnt better than quis, as the creature can still be shot, burned, drained, eaten etc, but not poisoned, anti-mattered, or frozen, etc.  and the ball lightening generator, as you call it, only makes a ball lightning after a successful attack, a lobo/shield (or killing it, obv) would stop it dead in its tracks.  the cost of the card is spelled out in the notes, incorporating the sparks/ball lightnings as 1|2 cost respectively.

[karis]

its mostly just a popularity contest.

wow!   i have 3.7% popularity   

should i be glad with that?   

[kobisjeruk]

i bet some peeps are voting without actually having a close look at the cards in question...especially if you're advertising your submissions in chat (you know who you are)
take KDZ's Book of Life for example, did you even wondered why this is a permanent when it acts exactly like a spell?
nobody seems to question it, not even Card Curator themselves

how odd

[smuglapse]

i bet some peeps are voting without actually having a close look at the cards in question...especially if you're advertising your submissions in chat (you know who you are)
take KDZ's Book of Life for example, did you even wondered why this is a permanent when it acts exactly like a spell?
nobody seems to question it, not even Card Curator themselves

how odd

I think the Card Curators are mainly concerned with submissions complying with the rules and don't have the time to comment on any design flaws.

You can also mention how severely underpowered sacrificing one of your own creatures is to stop one creature's attack for one turn is, when the game already has Sundial to stop all creatures attacks for one turn, and Antimatter which converts an attack to healing.

Apparently, ideas don't win competitions--campaigning does.

[kobisjeruk]

those who campaign the hardest wins election
its a sad world we live in, yes

[SunnyGreens]

Apparently, ideas don't win competitions--campaigning does.

Where would this campaigning be going on?

[smuglapse]

Apparently, ideas don't win competitions--campaigning does.

Where would this campaigning be going on?

...especially if you're advertising your submissions in chat (you know who you are)

[SunnyGreens]

Apparently, ideas don't win competitions--campaigning does.

Where would this campaigning be going on?

...especially if you're advertising your submissions in chat (you know who you are)

Ah, kind of hard to judge for myself then.

[BC]

Nothing new. I would have hoped this forum has less of that, but guess not.