ICONS FOR DONORS - VOTING

[SpikeSpiegel]

Ok folks, time to vote! We decided to make just one poll, so you're going to vote the whole submission for each contestant.

Choose wisely and may the best work win!

Spoiler for UTAlan:

Level 1:
Level 2:
Level 3:
Level 4:

Spoiler for SpikeSpiegel:

Tier 1, Bronze Star:
Tier 2, Silver Star:
Tier 3, Gold Star:
Tier 4, Platinum Star:

Spoiler for jarozaoz:

Tier 1, Bronze Heart Badge from EtG Forum for founding:
Tier 2, Silver Heart Badge from EtG Forum for founding:
Tier 3, Golden Heart Badge from EtG Forum for founding:
Tier 4, Indium Heart Badge from EtG Forum for founding:

Spoiler for eljoemo:

Small Donation ($5 - $19.99) - 
Medium Donation ($20 - $79.99) - 
Large Donation ($80 - $319.99) - 
Huge Donation ($320 +) - 

Spoiler for artimies7:

[Naesala]

I loved a lot of these, but I think jarozoaz's piece is the absolute best, so i only voted for that piece.

[vrt]

Anyone who didn't make theirs from scratch should be linking their source material. People will be effectively buying these icons, copyright is an issue.




also 32x32px looks ridiculuos

[eljoemo]

Did ARTH technically make a submission or was he just showing artimies how to resize his images?

[SpikeSpiegel]

Did ARTH technically make a submission or was he just showing artimies how to resize his images?

He resized artimies icons: but since they are in a competition thread and they are regular, they've been added to the poll. We couldn't considered them as artimies icons since he didn't do them.

If ARTHANASIOS doesn't want to take part of the poll, we'll remove it.


EDIT: Since Artimies DID the icons and there was only a size issue, we're goin' to edit the poll and removing arthanasios submission. Sorry, my fault.

[SpikeSpiegel]

There was a misunderstanding about competition submission. The poll has been edited and votes count resetted. Sorry for the inconvenience.

[SpikeSpiegel]

Anyone who didn't make theirs from scratch should be linking their source material. People will be effectively buying these icons, copyright is an issue.




also 32x32px looks ridiculuos

My star comes from: http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Award_star-gold-3d.svg

[Odii Odsen]

Voted.

1. eljoemo
2. jarozaoz

[Submachine]

I was hesitating between Spike, eljoe and Jaro, but then eljoe and Jaro got my votes because their colorings give away the feeling of each league better (Spike's Platinum looks like a huge bronze)

[TribalTrouble]

I recommend to edit the last post in the now locked topic with a link to this one since people followed that and it did not note that this WAS created.

[jarozaoz]

UTAlan and arti submissions are not that bad at all, but their compression to small resolution is...  ...unsuccesful. :/
Spike and eljo works are a lot better imo, and they deserve my vote. To be honest, i wasn't been able to decide, which icons are the best. 

And thanks for voice of anyone who voted on this competition. It's really needed. ♥

[artimies7]

Looking at the comments, I don't think I'm going to win. YEah. That's ok, though. I tried and I think if I had spent as much time as I did on these icons and had just made them the small sizes to begin with, I'd be a bit more competitive. Good luck to everyone else, though!