Forum name Card competition voting!

[Scaredgirl]

I set it as one of the conditions, because that was meant to be part of the challenge..

Yes, but why? There has been tons of earlier card idea competitions and we've never demanded Crucible ready before. This competition sounds like a "fun competition", yet the rules are more strict than any other competition. One small visual mistake and you are disqualified. Makes no sense.

I posted them directly from a pm judging each of the different cards, so that has whether or not their flawed posted. I think this is important, because it is still my opinion that you should consider this in your voting.

I agree with girlsgeneration on this. Labeling some submissions as "FLAWED" is a very poor choice of words and will definitely affect the vote. There's a big difference in saying "Missing artist name" or shouting "FLAWED" with red letters.

But that being said, it's not enough to restart the vote. I'm just saying for future reference because the most important thing about the vote is to try to make it as fair as possible.

[Purity_Riot]

I envisioned this as a challenging competition, not a fun one. I did however change it as per your demands. I'll go back and removed Kael's comments on the cards now as well.

[Kael Hate]

I agree with girlsgeneration on this. Labeling some submissions as "FLAWED" is a very poor choice of words and will definitely affect the vote. There's a big difference in saying "Missing artist name" or shouting "FLAWED" with red letters.

For those who aren't staff and maybe unaware, the FLAWED  and READY comments that appear(ed) at the bottom of the entries was copied over from a review of whether the card was Crucible ready and not a measurement of any competition legality beyond crucible ready status. There is no weighting within that measurement, if it would not have moved to the crucible at the time of review because of a flaw it was marked FLAWED. This could have been something as simple as an incorrectly used icon to a total failure in respect to the crucible criteria. Note - Such review does not consider the competiiton rules in any way and it is at the Competiton Organisers evaluation if a candidate fulfils the competiton rules.

[Dragoon1140]

For those who aren't staff and maybe unaware, the FLAWED  and READY comments that appear(ed) at the bottom of the entries was copied over from a review of whether the card was Crucible ready and not a measurement of any competition legality beyond crucible ready status. There is no weighting within that measurement, if it would not have moved to the crucible at the time of review because of a flaw it was marked FLAWED. This could have been something as simple as an incorrectly used icon to a total failure in respect to the crucible criteria. Note - Such review does not consider the competiiton rules in any way and it is at the Competiton Organisers evaluation if a candidate fulfils the competiton rules.

Well in my case, you posted the following in my card idea thread:

CURATOR COMMENT

To get to the Crucible
- Change the Element to "Fire". ( means Fire Quanta, not the element Fire)
- Leave the Atk|Hp blank

Both of these deal with the table, are purely aesthetic, and does not, and should not, prevent a card from entering the competition.  That normally wouldn't bother me though, if I was given a reasonable amount of time to change it.  I was sleeping when you sent that post, so when I woke up I posted the response.

This is what I posted six hours later:

Done and done.  Thanks for the info.   

You responded minutes later saying it was Crucible ready.  However, that didn't matter because the competition ended shortly after you posted the warning.

I have absolutely no problem with setting a card to Crucible standards when it is asked of me, it would be silly to think that.  I just have a problem with the warning given to me just a few hours before the competition ended.

[moomoose]

too late to throw my hat in the ring? if so no biggie. phantom fox is gonna win anyway.
http://elementscommunity.org/forum/index.php/topic,10185.0.html

[Dragoon1140]

too late to throw my hat in the ring? if so no biggie. phantom fox is gonna win anyway.
http://elementscommunity.org/forum/index.php/topic,10185.0.html

It is too late, but that is the cutest card I've ever seen.

[Purity_Riot]

and the winner by 5 votes is.....

Phantom Fox!

You will be receiving your award very shortly.

[Purity_Riot]

Topic Locked!