Thaw

[thearchduke]

Simple fire concept: thaw target creature.  Guess who wins the poison/fire fight now, bitch...

[Uncle Jellyfish]

Simple fire concept: thaw target creature.  Guess who wins the poison/fire fight now, bitch...

LOL! Thaw has been suggested somewhere...I think, lol. I think it would be a good card, and it would balance out Speed Fire vs Speed Poison, lol, but Thaw, just like Purify, would be very situational. It's a counter to a single effect, and has no other effect outside of that.

[thearchduke]

Could make it broader, like a purify for creatures.  I'm thinking Trial by Fire (2 Fire, 1 Upped) - Lowers HP -3, removes all enchantments and effects from creature.  Or, -2 HP, removes all enchantments, effects AND abilities from creature.

[Terroking]

the only card you want to lost the ability of is drags, or your opponents if it can be used on them

[Uncle Jellyfish]

I think that Thaw would be more balanced as a creature ability, so that it's not entirely useless in your hand, but has the chance of being countered, and makes it a priority target vs. your other creatures.

[Forfeit]

This has been suggested before. By me; I actually just posted something new on that topic. It was generally agreed upon that a single spell card to thaw a creature was useless, but a creature ability sounds great. (Another suggestion i made on that forum that everyone ignored in favor of debating over the spell).

[thearchduke]

What about something broader that would affect the whole army?  And, sorry to duplicate the thread, here's the link:

http://elementstheforum.smfforfree3.com/index.php/topic,519.0.html

[Forfeit]

Something that affect more creatures would be useful, but what if you only have one really strong creature out, you can't just stack on thaw spells. I think a creature or permanet would be the best way to go.

P.S. You are now one of my favorite elements people for putting a link to my forum up : )

[Terroking]

lol, i noticed the creature idea, for some reason i was thinking of it as a red octopus with 4 arms and yellow dots... but that's just one crazed theory

[Evil Hamster]

It would have to be a creature immune to freezing, or the ability should be usable while frozen otherwize that would be the first creature frozen!

[Uncle Jellyfish]

It would have to be a creature immune to freezing, or the ability should be usable while frozen otherwize that would be the first creature frozen!

Well, that would be the balance, wouldn't it? XD

[Evil Hamster]

You could just use Anubis for that matter... Sure it won't unfreeze a creature, but once immortal it can't be frozen again.