This card...Since the shield thing not happening makes it useless, maybe it could have that Squire thing as something similar to Endow, an activated ability vs. the current, either I take your shield and protect you myself, or I suck. I think this card should not be set to suck should it come into play and you not have a shield for him to grab. If anything, I think he should be better than crusader, since it takes some set-up, while sader can use any weapon, at any time, assuming it does not die.