Axe Barbarian | Axepert Barbarian

[Pineapple]

dejavu don't have that 'permanently'  and 'always' is only 1 creature card.  isn't it?   

If "permanently" is only used in 1 creature card, then of course "always" means only one creature card. I said "In Elements, 'permanently' has always meant that the ability can only be used once." A counter-example showing the proposition false would be the use of "permanently" to mean otherwise. Deja Vu is not a counter-example.

[Prnc Athrr]

dejavu don't have that 'permanently'  and 'always' is only 1 creature card.  isn't it?   

If "permanently" is only used in 1 creature card, then of course "always" means only one creature card. I said "In Elements, 'permanently' has always meant that the ability can only be used once." A counter-example showing the proposition false would be the use of "permanently" to mean otherwise. Deja Vu is not a counter-example.

+1.. :3

[furballdn]

Don't really see how thematically he loses 1 health. Perhaps you could make his ability called "Axe grind" or "Axe sharpen". That would make more sense as he'd be sharpening his axes (increasing attack), and he could also hurt himself in the process (axes are sharp). As for whether it's overpowered or underpowered, it's quite fine as it is. You're paying 7 for a 7|5 creature. Compare that with Shrieker which is 8 for 8|3.