Witch | Witch and Cauldron | Magical Cauldron

[RagingAlien]

NAME: Witch ELEMENT: Darkness COST: 4  TYPE: Creature ATK|HP: 2|7 TEXT: Cauldron: Generate a Cauldron.	NAME: Witch ELEMENT: Darkness COST: 3  TYPE: Creature ATK|HP: 3|7 TEXT: Magical Cauldron: Generate a Magical Cauldron.

ART: http://www.sxc.hu/photo/1087848 IDEA: an alien NOTES: ***Insert additional information*** SERIES:

NAME: Cauldron ELEMENT: Earth COST: 2 TYPE: Creature ATK|HP: 0|6 TEXT: Alchemy: If a Witch is on the field, generate an alchemy potion and give it to any creature in play.	NAME: Magical Cauldron ELEMENT: Earth COST: 2 TYPE: Creature ATK|HP: 0|6 TEXT: Alchemy: If a Witch is on the field, generate a benefiting alchemy potion and give it to any allied creature.

ART: http://www.sxc.hu/photo/901792 IDEA: an alien NOTES: This is a Token card, like Ash. AKA: cannot be played directly from hand. It is also Unique, and there can only be one in each field (no alchemy spamming for you!) Adrenaline Quintessence Basilisk Blood Luciferin Black Hole Black Hole and Luciferin are included since they are ALWAYS benefitial to the user, even if they aren't used on specific creatures. Nymph's Tears is not in the list because somethimes that One pillar that gets converted was more than necessary. SERIES:

[RagingAlien]

Oh, come on now. Is this card so awful/awesome that nobody has anything to say about it?

[Flayne]

i suggest it generates a random potion from the 12 elements, like antimatter or quint or luci, etc.
but overall. the concept is cool.
I find that the witch is too expensive.

7 + 3 + 3 to generate a quintessence that costs 3.

its basically 13 quanta to produce something that costs 3 quanta.

thats far too expensive.

I suggest lowering witch to 4 unnupped and 3 upped and lowering cauldron creation skill to 2 , then lowering cauldron ability to 2 .

3+2+2 = 7 quanta to produce something of 3 quanta sounds much better imo.

[RagingAlien]

Hmm... good point. (+3 turns, too, but lower costs than that is way too low.) Thanks for the quanta balance, updating it now.

[OldTrees]

As a rule: Cards that require a trio of quanta sources to be usable are not versatile enough to be a valuable addition to ETG.
Why would this case be different?

[RagingAlien]

Should i change Cauldron generation to too?

It is an option, since both and work with steel.

[OldTrees]

Should i change Cauldron generation to too?

It is an option, since both and work with steel.

How about just forgetting about the witch? Cut out the middleman?

[RagingAlien]

Thing is, the cauldron would need the Witch to provide the alchemy. "The water won't turn on the fire alone, is it?" as said my mother when i was learning to make spaghetti.

[OldTrees]

Thing is, the cauldron would need the WitchElemental to provide the alchemy. "The water won't turn on the fire alone, is it?" as said my mother when i was learning to make spaghetti.

Fixed.
Players are quite qualified to brew potions.

[RagingAlien]

Ah, right. D'oh, dumb me. I liked the Witch idea, though... :/ will leave it there, but count it as if it didn't exist. i'm making a poll too. thanks again, Oldtrees.