Neurotoxin | Neurotoxin

[SteppingStone81]

I really like what you were trying to do, but I agree after thinking it through it isn't practical

I needed this thread to realise it too. I t is sad but it is so. Thanks for your support, moomoose.

Yeah, I didn't mean to sound so negative with my post.  I like the idea of introducing neurotoxin via a spell, but it is just too difficult to balance.  I like the art, too, btw!

[serprex]

Could this be balanced if it didn't add a poison counter? Then it'd require comboing with other poison cards, which doesn't have in-element. This would assume that Neurotoxin can only be applied to a target with a poison counter already

Dune Scorpions benefits over this would be reapplying Neurotoxin after the opponent uses Purify, and adding a poison counter on every hit. Whereas this wouldn't require attack raising effects

NB and , elements with poison, don't have attack raising effects

[BeefSupreme]

Do you read the warning that says this thread is OLD and probably shouldn't be posted in before you post?

[serprex]

Yes, but I don't feel this idea came to a conclusion. Would it be better if I posted a new Neurotoxin | Neurotoxin with the proposed tweak? There's tension between "don't post in old topics" and "use the search feature"

If it's really a rule not to post in old topics, why aren't they autolocked?

[BeefSupreme]

This particular topic is REALLY old (seeing as the last post wasn't since the forum move), so I'd probably have made a new topic.
Either way, I think you've won the award for the oldest necro.

[ddevans96]

Either way, I think you've won the award for the oldest necro.

Not even close, really. There've been some from the last year of threads from as early as 2009.

[BeefSupreme]

Either way, I think you've won the award for the oldest necro.

Not even close, really. There've been some from the last year of threads from as early as 2009.

orly? Lame ;-;
Nevermind. You get nothing.

[rob77dp]

I guess since this topic has been "revived" (necro?), I'll add my idea to 'fixing' the card.

Leave cost alone at 4|3 and edit effect/text to:

"
Inflict 1 neurotoxin counter to target and 1 additional counter per card played next turn.
"

I think it could be 'fixed'/improved by limiting the turn duration of the build-up on the direct spell neuro (Dune is fine with continuous building as it requires combo and can be CC'd).

[skyironsword]

^ I don't think the owner is even still using this site.

[rob77dp]

^ I don't think the owner is even still using this site.

Who, SnoWeb?  According to 'this site' they were active most recently ~4.5 hrs ago.

[SnoWeb]

I'm no owner. You can use any of my card ideas to make it your own.
I'll just ask you one thing: please let these extremely old threads die in peace. No Futile medical care.

[skyironsword]

Neurotoxin lies here
It was a noble card
May it rest in peace.