Chibaki | Manbaki

[ZephyrPhantom]

How does this look for art?

[Rutarete]

How does this look for art?

That might work, though I'll need to decide which part I want to crop.

Intersting method of providing some anti-CC into . There is still a lot of room on the card, so it might be good to provide a little more explaination into the card text though since players may not intuitively know what "smoke" does.

As an amusing sidenote, "Chibaki" sounds very close to a word in the Seminole languate that roughly translates late to "complaining"... It gave me a chuckle

I'll see if I can fit "smoke cloaks the field on a(n adjacent) slot."

[Rutarete]

Bump. I'd like feedback in particular on this, besides anything else:

1: Make it so that Smoke goes away after a while and allow the original smoke spreader to hide itself, or
2. Have Smoke be permanent and the spreader not be able to be hidden by it (or at least by its own smoke).

[artimies7]

Bump. I'd like feedback in particular on this, besides anything else:

1: Make it so that Smoke goes away after a while and allow the original smoke spreader to hide itself, or
2. Have Smoke be permanent and the spreader not be able to be hidden by it (or at least by its own smoke).

Smoke should dissipate after so many turns, IMHO.

Also: I don't think Smoke should have an impact on your ability to use buffs, but it should give the creatures within the smoke a small miss chance.

[Rutarete]

Bump. I'd like feedback in particular on this, besides anything else:

1: Make it so that Smoke goes away after a while and allow the original smoke spreader to hide itself, or
2. Have Smoke be permanent and the spreader not be able to be hidden by it (or at least by its own smoke).

Smoke should dissipate after so many turns, IMHO.

Also: I don't think Smoke should have an impact on your ability to use buffs, but it should give the creatures within the smoke a small miss chance.

I'm curious as to why. Using the normal cloak card does not affect accuracy nor buffs - and Chibaki is simply cloaking. Especially if the smoke would go away, adding a miss chance makes it UP.

[artimies7]

Bump. I'd like feedback in particular on this, besides anything else:

1: Make it so that Smoke goes away after a while and allow the original smoke spreader to hide itself, or
2. Have Smoke be permanent and the spreader not be able to be hidden by it (or at least by its own smoke).

Smoke should dissipate after so many turns, IMHO.

Also: I don't think Smoke should have an impact on your ability to use buffs, but it should give the creatures within the smoke a small miss chance.

I'm curious as to why. Using the normal cloak card does not affect accuracy nor buffs - and Chibaki is simply cloaking. Especially if the smoke would go away, adding a miss chance makes it UP.

It's a thematic thing. I'm not pushing it, but I am going to advise brainstorming so as not to ignore the option of not being totally redundant with Cloak.

[Rutarete]

Do you feel it's too redundant right now?

[artimies7]

Do you feel it's too redundant right now?

Not alone, but if there's any other cards that would create localized Cloak you'll be taking over their function, and that's not good for card development.

[Rutarete]

Do you feel it's too redundant right now?

Not alone, but if there's any other cards that would create localized Cloak you'll be taking over their function, and that's not good for card development.

Well, that depends regarding precedence, but I see your point.