Black Shard

[Pegasus]

Please post some Replys



Thanks
Pegasus

[Kael Hate]

The Card is extremely situational. You could add a creature with 5 attack in its place, it will counter the lifegain and if they don't have shards, kill them quicker.

You could also use Deflag or Steal and simply take it from them and if they don't have a SoG it can destroy/take a pillar instead.

My Vote is nay to this card and the idea.

[Pegasus]

 

[Kael Hate]

Why Cry, everything I have said is true.


Why do you want to particularly attack the SoG? What is your idea you want to develop into a card? Is it a shard that is corrupted that you want to make? Is it something else. Your idea is just shown to us as a card with no background idea and a weak mechanic there is not much more we can do with just that.

[chuckles4me]

Perhaps a better use of this idea is to cause 5 points of damage/ turn.  The opposite of the healing effect.  This would have independent uses, rather than being tied to another card.

Just a thought.

I like the art though.

[Pegasus]

and i think more cards = more fun in this game.....
god cards or bad cards.....

and this cards deals 5 damage ( i changed this)

[kev]

I kind of like the idea of adding cards specifically intended to have in your sideboard for pvp tournies, which is essentially what this is.

Few people will build this into a deck but it might add an element of strategy to try to guess whether your opponent will keep his shards in his deck after match 1 of 5.

[PhantomFox]

Bad cards are bad for the game.  Mainly because the time and effort coding them could have been spent making a GOOD card.

As for this card, it seems like "RAWR I HATE SOGs, LET'S MAKE A SPECIFIC COUNTER-CARD!" with a small bit of damage tacked on for show.  Deflag is more useful than this in destruction, and bolts are more useful for damage.

Pass.

[BloodMaster50]

 :)coool really good idea

[MdbK]

Pros of the card:
Gets rid of the opponent's Shard of Gratitude,
Deals 5 Damage

Cons of the card:
1. Hardly any SoGs outside of a few FGs and T50, and won't be used otherwise...
2. 5 Damage is hardly any damage for such a card.
3. There's other cards out there that would be easier to use, such as Deflagration that can destroy the SoG or OTHER PERMANENTS.

This card was a good idea, but it would be stupid if it was implemented like this.

[Pegasus]

I only play aether.... and i dont have things like fire bolt ore something like that...
i would use this cards

[PhantomFox]

Yes, but you're not designing a card for YOU.  You're designing a card for EVERYONE.  Especially when you make it neutral element.