Best Weapon Idea Contest entry - Soul Eater / Soul Harvester

[Bloodshadow]

Should ATK gradually recover? I know that ATK reduction is currently irreversible, but killing a creature is even more irreversible. Even damaging a creature is hardly reversible; when you face an Owl's Eye, how often do you have HP buffs in your decks anyways?

[K1N5L4Y3R]

3 damage per turn ability is 5 ,shades are 2/1 vampire with 1 poison counter(only last one turn more with eclipse if you dun heal them) reduce enemy hp by 1 (not creature)

[Bloodshadow]

Really, you're nerfing this beyond its limits. 5 for ability cost is too much.

And stop complaining about the weapon damage. 5 is not much. Eagle's Eye deals 7 per turn, and it has uber creature control.

[K1N5L4Y3R]

I am not complaining, I like your original idea, but I am showing an option for those that are screaming OP all the time

[llVllonster]

with all the darkness death decks out there i think the shades might still be overdoing in a little bit think about genrating a shade everyturn and having an extra bonesheild. or even a mutation deck off of this weapon. the point is you can do way to much with it. look at all the other weapons what can you do with them they all have one simple purpose so you might want to edit this.

[Bloodshadow]

...What? Having multiple purposes is bad?

[llVllonster]

for one card if it has too many purposes it can still be considered op im not trying to nerf the card im just trying to help you form it. i really like the idea but no other card so far has 2 abilities.

[Bloodshadow]

for one card if it has too many purposes it can still be considered op im not trying to nerf the card im just trying to help you form it. i really like the idea but no other card so far has 2 abilities.

Sundial.

And Soul Eater has one ability. It doesn't have too many "purposes", but it synergizes with many other cards. Which is a GOOD thing.

[llVllonster]

depends how you look at it lobomitizer how many cards does it have synergy with?

[Bloodshadow]

You're making a poor comparison. How many cards does Bone Wall synergize with?

[omerbey]

I think this card is not OP at all.
But, who cares about what I think

I do have a slight problem with creature generation though, even if it's only possible with nightfall.
And the reason is I want creature factories to be limited to a small group of elements. Not that it's a super powerful ability.

[llVllonster]

but bone wall isnt a rare this is a rare