Songbird | Nightingale

[YoYoBro]

Excellent analysis, I agree with his point. And the mechanic, especially because of the "ways to awaken a sleeping creature". Good job

[Ajit]

Thanks for the comment there YoYoBro

[doublecross]

I thought of a solution that would kill two birds with one stone, so to speak:

When lull is used, it ends silence effecting either player.


It would make sense: something that is already on the field breaking the silence.

Also, that would address complaints that this card is too UP. This would buff it slightly, but only in certain contexts.

[YoYoBro]

Also, I'd add "A dragon is summoned" to the possible waking-up reasons. A dragon is everything but silent.

[ArtCrusade]

I just love this card! Cute mechanic which is balanced already!

[Ajit]

I thought of a solution that would kill two birds with one stone, so to speak:

When lull is used, it ends silence effecting either player.


It would make sense: something that is already on the field breaking the silence.

Also, that would address complaints that this card is too UP. This would buff it slightly, but only in certain contexts.

Very nice idea there doublecross.  I'll add this to the notes.

Also, I'd add "A dragon is summoned" to the possible waking-up reasons. A dragon is everything but silent.

Yet another good addition I'll add it, but I'm probably going to remove a few of the things that will wake it up, to prevent this card from being too weak.

I just love this card! Cute mechanic which is balanced already!

Thanks there ArtCrusade

[YoYoBro]

If I were you, I'd remove nova/supernova... after all, it's not so rare that a nova or a supernova explode, but they should be too far to actually cause any noise... sound moves at 300m/s and if they were so close as to hear they explode... they would instantly annihilate us elementals

Also, don't forget to check some of my older cards

[Ajit]

wait I don't know what you mean by check your older cards...?

Anyways thanks for the suggestions

[YoYoBro]

I just meant leave feedback on my Collection - YoYoBro topic or on my other cards' topic so that I know what you think of them

[Ajit]

Oh I see.. even though it seems quite unrelated.  I'll take a look some time.

[YoYoBro]

No problem, just advertising my cards not to let the main topic be necroed for curators' and viewers' sake