Whoa, whoa, whoa... That's good! It kinda represents the original artwork for them. The recent artwork in the game doesn't even look like a "toad" or "puff"y. Nice art you got there! I think I would like if the red one is the unupgraded one (Toad Fish) and then upgraded to the more badass puffer version (Puffer Fish).
yaay Im really glad you like it
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/9e495/9e4952bc0df2248e21c9a92c0759195868ea4a3d" alt="Silly :silly:"
! Yeah, the current one looks very impresive; Althou as you say, it is no toad nor puff; I think it is better work than mine (in most aspects; not all) but would fit best as a different fish card.
I would do a Toadfish
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/6cb25/6cb25c56ede1975dcd80ce7fe52bb1f0e872acc4" alt="Water :water"
if it would be used, but guess that's not happening for now. OR I would do a Toadfish if there was a request for it.
Next I think I will do Mida's touch, Innovation, Hammer... (and fix ferrogolem)
Unless I recieve some specific request.