dusk mantle + weapon = miss

[crimson2006]

in no way what so ever should an opponents dusk mantle be able to make my weapon miss unless its a flying weapon. I'm 100% positive in this bug unlike my last post on a similar issue.

[killsdazombies]

actually dusk mantle applys to all attacks... including weapons.

[Kamietsu]

actually dusk mantle applys to all attacks... including weapons.

The above is correct. Shields apply to all damage sources except creatures with momentum, and the Titan weapon.

[crimson2006]

hahaha...could have fooled me when the card states "the attacking creatures..."...I do suggest it be changed to "physical damage" like the dimensional shield... oh, and don't say a weapon is a creature because the flying weapon states "makes your weapon into a creature" would clearly not be in the game if a weapon is already a creature...

[jigga456]

I think this needs to be clarified. The Procrastination shield says "any creature that damaged you..." but it doesn't apply to weapons. The Dusk Mantle says "the attacking creatures have..." but it does apply to weapons. Seems inconsistent.

Also, what about the Thorn carapice and the Fog shield. Both mention creatures as well, but does the Thorn carapice poison you if you hit it with a weapon and does the Fog shield block weapons also? I haven't checked either out yet.

[Kamietsu]

I think this needs to be clarified. The Procrastination shield says "any creature that damaged you..." but it doesn't apply to weapons. The Dusk Mantle says "the attacking creatures have..." but it does apply to weapons. Seems inconsistent.

Also, what about the Thorn carapice and the Fog shield. Both mention creatures as well, but does the Thorn carapice poison you if you hit it with a weapon and does the Fog shield block weapons also? I haven't checked either out yet.

No to the Carapice Shield, yes to the Fog Shield.

[BluePriest]

Very simple way of looking at it

Damage reduction and Hit Chance=Effects Weapons
Everything Else=Doesnt