[Official] Immortal | Elite Immortal

[Pineapple]

Obviously, it's not this that's UP, but quints that are OP

Hm...making it have X chance to regen Y health (maybe 1?) per turn actually sounds kind of fun...

[silux]

To make it really immortal you must give it an ability to ignore shield effects.(As momentum)
However the true problem about this card is that is weak and you can't combo with it.
Once you play one is a dead card for player and opponent;no one can target it, both in good or bad way.

It would be good for aether a spell that target both opponent's creature and player's ones.In this way immortal can be a bonus, because he won't suffer from the spell.
Or a passive buff to all creature player control, like eclipse but for aether.

[glopso]

The immortal should be able to live forever, even if you deck out.

[furballdn]

To make it really immortal you must give it an ability to ignore shield effects.(As momentum)
However the true problem about this card is that is weak and you can't combo with it.
Once you play one is a dead card for player and opponent;no one can target it, both in good or bad way.

It would be good for aether a spell that target both opponent's creature and player's ones.In this way immortal can be a bonus, because he won't suffer from the spell.
Or a passive buff to all creature player control, like eclipse but for aether.

Giving it momentum would be OP.

[glopso]

To make it really immortal you must give it an ability to ignore shield effects.(As momentum)
However the true problem about this card is that is weak and you can't combo with it.
Once you play one is a dead card for player and opponent;no one can target it, both in good or bad way.

It would be good for aether a spell that target both opponent's creature and player's ones.In this way immortal can be a bonus, because he won't suffer from the spell.
Or a passive buff to all creature player control, like eclipse but for aether.

Giving it momentum would be OP.

What if you gave it overdrive AND momentum?

[Xenocidius]

To make it really immortal you must give it an ability to ignore shield effects.(As momentum)
However the true problem about this card is that is weak and you can't combo with it.
Once you play one is a dead card for player and opponent;no one can target it, both in good or bad way.

It would be good for aether a spell that target both opponent's creature and player's ones.In this way immortal can be a bonus, because he won't suffer from the spell.
Or a passive buff to all creature player control, like eclipse but for aether.

Giving it momentum would be OP.

What if you gave it overdrive AND momentum?

Momentum doesn't fit the theme of Aether. At all. Neither does Overdrive.

[CCCombobreaker]

While 'momentum' doesn't fit, being unblockable could reasonably be an extension of what aether does.  That material shields affect immaterial creatures is kinda weird from a theoretical standpoint.

[Naesala]

Just make it "Immortal does not die when HP=0 or less"

[Pineapple]

: Phase
2 random immaterial creatures or weapons, plus Immortal, ignore shields for one turn.

So, the Immortal that uses this ability gains momentum, then, 3 out of all the immaterial cards you have on the field (including the Immortal that uses this ability) gains momentum, so if you have 6 immortals and 17 non-immortal immaterial creatures, and each immortal uses "phase", then you can have anywhere from 6 to 18, out of 23, momentum creatures each turn.

[Naesala]

: Phase
2 random immaterial creatures or weapons, plus Immortal, ignore shields for one turn.

So, the Immortal that uses this ability gains momentum, then, 3 out of all the immaterial cards you have on the field (including the Immortal that uses this ability) gains momentum, so if you have 6 immortals and 17 non-immortal immaterial creatures, and each immortal uses "phase", then you can have anywhere from 6 to 18, out of 23, momentum creatures each turn.

Sounds like much to much.

[furballdn]

Just make it "Immortal does not die when HP=0 or less"

Would phase dragon get that same effect? If not, then immortal is the better choice as it's unaffected by both weight shield and fire shield.

[Pineapple]

: Phase
2 random immaterial creatures or weapons, plus Immortal, ignore shields for one turn.

So, the Immortal that uses this ability gains momentum, then, 3 out of all the immaterial cards you have on the field (including the Immortal that uses this ability) gains momentum, so if you have 6 immortals and 17 non-immortal immaterial creatures, and each immortal uses "phase", then you can have anywhere from 6 to 18, out of 23, momentum creatures each turn.

Sounds like much to much.

An average of 12 per turn after quinting all 23 of your monsters and paying 18 per turn?
To be fair, it's much less OP than:

Just make it "Immortal does not die when HP=0 or less"