[Official] Fate Egg | Fate Egg

[Dengeki]

  please do nothing to this egg, it would ruin my 'scrambled eggs', deck. i think its just fine the way it is.

[rosutosefi]

please do nothing to this egg, it would ruin my 'scrambled eggs', deck. i think its just fine the way it is.

We're planning on buffing it.

[Dengeki]

i think its just fine the way it is, doesnt need a buff. buffing it would iether shut off its already powerful utility, or make it cheaper than it really needs to be causeing my scrambled eggs deck to become unbalanced and even more way too powerfull. i mean am i not gonna be up set when it cost 2 or 1 to play, not really, since i will have first turn 6 possible dragons. but it costing 3 is what keeps it fair for my opponents, it means at best usuall hand i may have 2-4 dragons first turn. but if it cost 2 or 1 i could easily obtain 4-6 dragons by second turn.( iknow it pops with low crap. but for me this is only about 35% of the time. rest of time i get retarded awesome). and if you add those other ideas to it, it would loose the benifit of SoR. like burrowed for example. and i dont think it should pop with mutants thats  's domain.
 

[omegareaper7]

i think its just fine the way it is, doesnt need a buff. buffing it would iether shut off its already powerful utility, or make it cheaper than it really needs to be causeing my scrambled eggs deck to become unbalanced and even more way too powerfull. i mean am i not gonna be up set when it cost 2 or 1 to play, not really, since i will have first turn 6 possible dragons. but it costing 3 is what keeps it fair for my opponents, it means at best usuall hand i may have 2-4 dragons first turn. but if it cost 2 or 1 i could easily obtain 4-6 dragons by second turn.( iknow it pops with low crap. but for me this is only about 35% of the time. rest of time i get retarded awesome). and if you add those other ideas to it, it would loose the benifit of SoR. like burrowed for example. and i dont think it should pop with mutants thats  's domain.
 

so you want it to remain a joke card? because at the moment, thats all it is.

[Dengeki]

well no i dont want any card to be a joke card. but i dont want any card to become overpowered or broken. i think it has what it needs to do at what price in should be compared to what it can be combo'd with, and also its advantages over some shields, and if it changes it will then make certain other cards even more useless.  plus with the forge trying to make cards that lay eggs, and make eggs, its going to become extra broken. i just feal it is already a balanced card; from price to ability. especially in the over-all possible future of this game. and besides i thought when they upped the SoR- that was all the upgrade fate egg needed. like i said if it gets cheaper great my deck becomes even more overpowered than it already is, if it gets 0/+2 stat boost wont make a single difference, if it is burrowed becomes a useless card for time shard, and mutate is  's domain.  however the reverse time thing is kinda interesting but is it worth the work to add that much code to track cards that were once eggs, not to mention egg +SoR, rewind one-and SoR that one-Tada !!!! broken like deja vu rewind stall...
 

[Firenotes]

I think a small chance to hatch a mutant is a good upgrade. as for cost reduction and like comments I have to disagree. The cost is fine, the ability cost is fine. If you up it's def then other cards decrease in usefullness. Burrow is horrible unless you can SoR it and fractal it as well or that comment gets sent to the "Nerf this card" area. All in all i think the egg is good as is and seeing all the card ideas and the future of the game If this card gets buffed I can see it getting nerfed in the future as well. Just my 2 cents from a newb to elements but a life long card player.

[omegareaper7]

well no i dont want any card to be a joke card. but i dont want any card to become overpowered or broken. i think it has what it needs to do at what price in should be compared to what it can be combo'd with, and also its advantages over some shields, and if it changes it will then make certain other cards even more useless.  plus with the forge trying to make cards that lay eggs, and make eggs, its going to become extra broken. i just feal it is already a balanced card; from price to ability. especially in the over-all possible future of this game. and besides i thought when they upped the SoR- that was all the upgrade fate egg needed. like i said if it gets cheaper great my deck becomes even more overpowered than it already is, if it gets 0/+2 stat boost wont make a single difference, if it is burrowed becomes a useless card for time shard, and mutate is  's domain.  however the reverse time thing is kinda interesting but is it worth the work to add that much code to track cards that were once eggs, not to mention egg +SoR, rewind one-and SoR that one-Tada !!!! broken like deja vu rewind stall...
 

A two card combo is easy to beat, also, immo rushes still would get damage out faster, giving it a buff would do nothing to hurt the game.

[tsgreen]

how about giving it a passive ability to hatch in 5 turns. That would be lobo protection, but no mutants... there annoying enough in 

[JonathanCrazyJ]

hatch in 5 turns lol... so a rush kills you when you have (maybe) 1 creature hatched? that would take FE down from being a bit underpowered to completely useless lol... passive hatch in 1 turn, maybe.

[Friedrich Psitalon]

I'd agree with the possibility of it hatching Mutants. It won't overshadow the Fallen Elf/Druid (repeated applications of that effect from one source) or the spell Mutation (unpreventable/lobotomizable, also usable in mono-entropy). It's fine for the effect to remain  instead of  .  Any card which has absolutely no use in any form of competitive environment does not contribute to that environment, and therefore might as well not exist.

"Fun" decks can come in a billion flavors, and a billion themes. You don't design cards for "fun" decks - theme decks can pop up anywhere, and always will. You want cards to have a specific, meaningful choice attached to them - even if it's a choice many players reject - for competitive play.

This one, right now, clearly does not.

[Dengeki]

after many more games with my platnum egg farmer deck, i was going to come back here and change my vote(doesnt seem to allow that though). and although i still firmly believe it should not pop with mutations not even a little.  but i was going to recast my vote for cost reduction to 2  .   my reasons are because time is actually a very quantum costly element. there are alot of abilities that require constant re-use costs. actually, not going to go into my reasons.  just wanted to change my vote.

[RavingRabbid]

Simple solution:

The "egghatch'd" creature enters play with a random 0-3 buff for every stat.