[Official] Cloak | Cloak

[Tyhaux2]

this card is worthless... its needs a buff. or something... even if its a 2 clock timer on it. its really not worth playing it for just 2 turns. i believe the clock should be raised for 3-4 turns and maybe even 5. but as far as it stands... something needs to happen with it...

[TheonlyrealBeef]

Uhm, Cloak already lasts for 3 turns :o
It's actually usable since that buff (see war ).

[Pineapple]

mass permanent/creature protection is far less than useless.

[wildgoldenpk]

This card is not useless, its annoying if an oppenent uses cloak.

[killybob]

hmm i suppose they could give it invulnerability to PC and erase the timer function to make it last forever... this card protects all your creatures and perms for 3 turns as well as preventing you from seeing what your opponent's doing. it has the ability to wreck some tactics and substantially slow down others. no buff.

[johannhowitzer]

Didn't I see a "Tyhaux" without the 2 not too long ago?

[Sevs]

I figure we are just supposed to add an existing topic.

Cloak is still kinda useless. you need to pack so many of them for them to really have an effect 3 turns?

This might be too strong but what if i hid the opponents side of the field too. meaning they could use abilities on their creatures/ permanents  but have it last less.

[tyranim]

this card is FAAR from useless. its kinda like a mass PA/quint that can be destroyed. its pretty powerful really.
if this card EVER needs a buff, i would go with your opponent not being able to see your quantum pool and cards you play.

[johannhowitzer]

Yeah, don't knock this card until you've tried several decks that use it.  I ran a Deathstalker/Nightfall deck that used Cloaks to give the fragile scorpions a bit more longevity... it was pretty brutal.

[Snopel]

The card is fairly useful but there is one problem that just makes the card useless.
You can SEE what CARDS they lay down!
My buff suggestion is to be able to cloak their hand too. Because if you can see what cards they put down, then what's the point? It's basically a mass immortality for 3 turns. And I think this will give a true meaning to Cloak.

[Hyroen]

The card is fairly useful but there is one problem that just makes the card useless.
You can SEE what CARDS they lay down!
My buff suggestion is to be able to cloak their hand too. Because if you can see what cards they put down, then what's the point? It's basically a mass immortality for 3 turns. And I think this will give a true meaning to Cloak.

I used to think that too, what shot the idea down was things like tournaments. How will you know if they're playing fairly or not. Though now that I think about it, you technically could ban Cloak from all tournaments should it be given that buff.

[Snopel]

The card is fairly useful but there is one problem that just makes the card useless.
You can SEE what CARDS they lay down!
My buff suggestion is to be able to cloak their hand too. Because if you can see what cards they put down, then what's the point? It's basically a mass immortality for 3 turns. And I think this will give a true meaning to Cloak.

I used to think that too, what shot the idea down was things like tournaments. How will you know if they're playing fairly or not. Though now that I think about it, you technically could ban Cloak from all tournaments should it be given that buff.

Well that is a good point... =|