Forum Brawl #7 - Round 1 - Voting

[mathman101]

Important Post

For our BOSS task, 'depict' does not mean a picture. 'depict' means use any form of description to create an image of a thing in another person's mind. the lore is not lore, it is the submission as a whole which depicts the scene. My character has depicted the scene to my partner back on Blistermarsh.

We had asked about that and were told that this round depict specifically meant art.

Joey:19:39 brawlmasters ask 3 artists tasks in the same week, pretty crazy if you ask me.

math:19:40 depict doesn't nesecarrily mean draw. you should sing a song about the two stars

math:19:40

Joey:19:42 I asked fippe and he said its art

[JonathanCrazyJ]

not specified, and allowed last brawl. You can't have a ruling secretive when there is precedence to the contrary.

ALSO

Well our plan was an image, but since we just say "depict", anything works really.

Above is from our private board

[Manuel]

also also:

Create a deck that represents a barren planet. It must be 50% : OR 50% . You can also use : and : cards from the Card Ideas & Art section.

Paratus used also  ,  and  cards

[Aves]

Spoiler for Mapper:

Depict your spaceship approaching an unknown solar system.

I think all teams got the idea, more or less. I'm finding it difficult to determine which submissions should get more points than others, and will likely vote in order of polish/clear design.

Spoiler for Space Trooper:

Depict your spaceship approaching an unknown solar system.

I see Aves, too, is mixing up Mapper and Space Trooper tasks

It says WIP for a reason! 

[CleanOnion]

Whether or not "depict" means "make a picture", the fact remains that neither GFY's submission nor half of IM's submission have been removed. So the Brawlmasters have decided, whether directly or otherwise, that for this task at least "depict" means whatever.

Beyond that it's in voter territory. Aves for example has already decided that for him, "depict" means "make a picture" and has voted accordingly. Other voters should have their own opinions and should make their votes based on those opinions.

[Aves]

Whether or not "depict" means "make a picture", the fact remains that neither GFY's submission nor half of IM's submission have been removed. So the Brawlmasters have decided, whether directly or otherwise, that for this task at least "depict" means whatever.

Beyond that it's in voter territory. Aves for example has already decided that for him, "depict" means "make a picture" and has voted accordingly. Other voters should have their own opinions and should make their votes based on those opinions.

I mean, if it was just about making an image, I wouldnt be giving them too many points either. My issue with your submission is less about "depict" than it is about "blue dwarf-stars."

[MyNameIsJoey]

For clarification, what fippe told me pretty much looked like : We intend it to be art. Do something else if you want but then you might get less votes.

[DoctorC]

Not voting, but still sharing our view on things. Nvm, apparently we are voting.

Spoiler for Captain Task:

Iron Manta:

Forgive me, I was never the artistic type.. more of a do-er.

First of all, how dare you. Second, we really don't think that that scheme is correct regardless of how much JCJ isn't an artist - We really doubt that binary stars have ever been recorded to actually have a planet flying between them every now and again, since most of them are way too close to each other and gravity would just pull the planet to one of the stars. And even if that was a case, do you really think that blue stars would've left this planet unharmed? According to the wikipedia (and very basic knowledge of astrophysics), Blue stars are ten times hotter than your average yellow dwarves (our Sun, for instance). So yeah, sorry, mate, but we don't think there'd be a planet that would survive that encounter, unless it's VERY far away from the cyan twins. Dunno if that was intentional or not, since JCJ has shown that he has done some planning, but we reckon, it might be better for him to return to the... *drawing* board, hehe.

Green night: Eh. Despite the fact that the task itself was quite dull - draw a pair of blue glowing balls surround by many white dots, we can't help but think that you lot could genuinely done a better job.

And then there's BGFY... Honestly, if we were allowed to vote and our submission wasn't there, we'd have to vote for Oinoin's doings.

Spoiler for Mapper Task:

Iron Manta: We're really surprised to see a 3d thing in this, and really disappointed that it doesn't look as well as it was intended. As an artist, we understand that rendering 3d objects is a pain like no other, but we can't help the fact that it just looks very, VERY unfinished. =/

Green Night: While this one does seem more believable than the boss task, it still carries a lot of flaws from that it's counterpart does. Another thing is avoiding to actually drawing your own ship's exterior, which is something we tried to do, but (credit to TribalTrouble) decided to actually do something, seeing how anything would've been better than nothing. Maybe carry this thought throughout the next rounds?

BGFY: There's a painful lack of detail in the task, which would make us think that there was some sort of color limitation or time handicap, if we didn't know any better.

So yeah, Iron Manta is probably the one we'd vote, provided ours wasn't an option.

Spoiler for General stuff:

also also:

Create a deck that represents a barren planet. It must be 50% : OR 50% . You can also use : and : cards from the Card Ideas & Art section.

Paratus used also  ,  and  cards

So? It has to be 50% either earth or gravy and the rest is up to us to decide. So our Space Trooper decided let's make a rainbow.

those damned priests

First of all, how dare you, twice. Second, we're not even correlated to a religion, we're ecologists D:

[Fippe94]

Paratus' Space Trooper submisison is against the task rules since it is using CIA cards that is not or cards. It will be removed from voting and Paratus will recieve 0 points for that task.

This also means that there is no point for Brawlers to vote on the Space Trooper task since the only legal vote would be 5 voints each to the other 2 teams.

[MyNameIsJoey]

This also means that there is no point for Brawlers to vote on the Space Trooper task since the only legal vote would be 5 voints each to the other 2 teams.

I don't understand this part. We are not allowed to vote for ourselves?

[CleanOnion]

@ji412jo

Players can not give any voting points to their own team.

@DoctorC

You are allowed to vote though

pls give points

[MyNameIsJoey]

so might as well not allow us to vote, since voting detriments us