We didn't have drama during the Brawl, so we have one after the Brawl, ehh...
Art is so subjective that the discussion which icon is better is useless.
The best solution imo, for the future brawls (or maybe for this one?) is to use the icon which won the bonus, but as a rule it should be added that winning icon can be modified (to an extent) to meet the winning team expectations. I think winners should have at least such the privilege.
I would also be ok with the rule that winners choose their own icon, but, on the other hand, do any participants in any RL events choose the reward they get? They get what they get, even if they don' like the reward... (I know that statement was against my team, sorry).
Well, to be honest, I prefer dragon icon, but I don't like any of the icons. I mean, as I stated earlier, totem is unthematic, and I also don't really like the andre's edit. Andre, I'm NOT impressed
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/be88e/be88e66ec9ae5f50bf361f131c04430ca98962e5" alt="Tongue :P"
(well, I actually don't like it's so pale (maybe increase saturation of the image a bit?), I don't like that six looks actually worse than before imo (it's squeezed too much, not as fiery as before, but on the other hand it resembles six better perhaps) and most of all I don't like it's so squary in the bottom-right corner). Dragon itself looks better than the original, but still I somehow don't like it.
But it's only damn forum icon, a bunch of pixels, I don't really care what I get. (I voted on the dragon though, just because I would know I got the icon for winnig Brawl 6 which was about killing the dragon, and not about finding a totem).