I also understand that this could lead to people not voting if they really want to win, so I propose either mandatory voting (with randomized vote if no vote is cast), or an "automatic vote" for your own team when you vote. Note that the latter solution is basically the same system as we already have, except it removes punishing "honorable" players, and removes a possible conflict among the team members.
I do take that issue up and answer it in my post.I also understand that this could lead to people not voting if they really want to win, so I propose either mandatory voting (with randomized vote if no vote is cast), or an "automatic vote" for your own team when you vote. Note that the latter solution is basically the same system as we already have, except it removes punishing "honorable" players, and removes a possible conflict among the team members.
Do team votes affect the placing in each round or do they have a separate scoring?Team votes have their own placing and scoring separate from the public placing.
Scoring -> 2. Team Vote
The team vote will occur much the same as the community votes, using the same table but posting within their secret sections. At least one vote per task must not be made on a fellow teammate (So, you can have a single vote for another team, or two votes, one for your team and one for another team). Each team has 6 Voting Power per role, and the team votes determine where this voting power is allocated eg 3 votes to one team, 2 to another, 1 to a third. These are added to the Community Votes.
Would it be possible to extend at least for 2-3 days the time for round 5 due to Easter?+1 for this
Would it be possible to extend at least for 2-3 days the time for round 5 due to Easter?+1 for this
Also agreed.Would it be possible to extend at least for 2-3 days the time for round 5 due to Easter?+1 for this
+2.Also agreed.Would it be possible to extend at least for 2-3 days the time for round 5 due to Easter?+1 for this
I'm totally in favor of this too.+2.Also agreed.Would it be possible to extend at least for 2-3 days the time for round 5 due to Easter?+1 for this
It'd mean 2 girls 1 brawl'd have enough time to finish their tasks properly.
I'm totally in favor of this too.+2.Also agreed.Would it be possible to extend at least for 2-3 days the time for round 5 due to Easter?+1 for this
It'd mean 2 girls 1 brawl'd have enough time to finish their tasks properly.
I'm a little late to the party on this, but have we considered simply having a few non-participant judges decide everything?
I'm a little late to the party on this, but have we considered simply having a few non-participant judges decide everything?
Aye i agree voting phase should be extended, there's so many things to vote on
I have a suggestion, Brawlmasters, don't you think voting phase for this HUGE round should be extended by 2 days to give people weekend for voting? There's only one community vote so far which sucks IMO.
Rules right now have nothing to prevent lazy copying votes by team members. The Team Votes section should be updated to require each player to give reasons for vote.
Not really, Brawl voting should be updated so that it doesn't depend on Brawler votes.
Rules right now have nothing to prevent lazy copying votes by team members. The Team Votes section should be updated to require each player to give reasons for vote.Not really, Brawl voting should be updated so that it doesn't depend on Brawler votes.
There are what, 2-3 community voters per round? That feels absurdly low. What makes it worse is that my singular vote is worth any three community votes put together, because I'm the only one in my team that voted. Voting definitely needs an overhaul, and I do agree that giving valid reasons is important-- but I think it any changes should go in the opposite direction-- make it easier to vote. Or at least incentivize it, rather than dis-incentivizing it. Ideally, we'd be able to have votes without Brawlers, but given the inactivity even from Brawlers, that doesn't seem quite feasible.
One option is a small modification to the current system-- only allow votes for other teams, but give some sort of advantage or statistic for those votes. E.g I vote for GP in 5 tasks and AB in one, and that gives LoS +6 Brawl Reputation, 1 per each task voted on per player. The Team with the most reputation in a given round gets a small bonus or something. Or heck, it could even be +1 point per full set of votes, forget who had the most. Does that give teams with more active players an advantage? Alright, then cap it to the smallest team's maximum voting potential or something. Another option could even have teams specify who is active and inactive, and base the system around that.
Just throwing ideas out.
Can I join????Brawl 6 will happen after War #10, which will probably start in a few months (after Trials). It's a long wait (trust me, I hate the wait just as much as you) but you're more than welcome to join then!
I support a separate expert panel for the next Brawl, and I would be willing to be a part of one if I'm still around.
Yes, what andretimpa says is basically what I had in mind too. The "expert" panel will in practice be nothing more than people who have to vote each round.
There is still a *looong* way until next Brawl, but I will say now that at least current plan (which might very well change of course) is to not have any team voting at all, instead voting will solely be from non-participants.
How are you going to boss Meaning Of Life V3 as Master of Death?Yes, what andretimpa says is basically what I had in mind too. The "expert" panel will in practice be nothing more than people who have to vote each round.
There is still a *looong* way until next Brawl, but I will say now that at least current plan (which might very well change of course) is to not have any team voting at all, instead voting will solely be from non-participants.
If that stays that way you likely have one Brawl boss right here.
/me raises hand
How are you going to boss Meaning Of Life V3 as Master of Death?Yes, what andretimpa says is basically what I had in mind too. The "expert" panel will in practice be nothing more than people who have to vote each round.
There is still a *looong* way until next Brawl, but I will say now that at least current plan (which might very well change of course) is to not have any team voting at all, instead voting will solely be from non-participants.
If that stays that way you likely have one Brawl boss right here.
/me raises hand