Forum Brawl #5 - Round 6 - Voting Phase

[Espithel]

Just want to say for voters that 'Espithel's Frustration' is an artist task not a Card Design task, if it had been in the task description or even labled "Artist/CD" we obviously would have made the card

This is correct.

I decided to make a card for kicks.

[JonathanCrazyJ]

Oh, also, are you allowed to make a challenge and then decline it? surely it is up to the challengee to accept or decline?

[rob77dp]

Several things here, CO:

1. Thank you for the hard work and effort you put into BM-ing (Zawadx too, but you seemed to be the main workshorse throughout)!

2. The spoiler is janky on the Bonus Task 3 starting with misspelling of spoiler on the AB submission.

3. Gaia's Pride is inaccurately listed without a submission for this. Please correct and in the meantime, voters see here for what was posted in the private section for this task:

Bonus Task 3 (Rnd 5 & 6):

Spoiler for Gaia's Pride:

A Tribute to Gaia's Pride...
Our team -- a proud COLLECTION!

fixnow-OKthanxbyenow.

[majofa]

Just want to say for voters that 'Espithel's Frustration' is an artist task not a Card Design task, if it had been in the task description or even labled "Artist/CD" we obviously would have made the card

This is correct.

I decided to make a card for kicks.

A transparent 'light' sword isn't very practical, though.   

(0 unrealistic traits means that the sword must be completely practical to use in a real life fight.

[Calambar]

If Abyss wins brawl, I will film myself dancing to nicki minaj.
This is a promise.

If you want to see that, vote on:

[CleanOnion]

Utmost apologies to Gaia's Pride, I do remember seeing that. It has been listed.

[Calambar]

Brawlmasters

Two errors I noticed:

Chaosomes' spoiler in bonus task is within our, Abyss Brawler's spoiler.

In the DB/Artist task LoS have this:

Click to expand
[img width=800px][/img]

Dunno if it was a LoS' mistake or Brawlmaster's

[CleanOnion]

Fixed!

The latter was LoS' mistake

Additionally team threads are now up, cheers to math for doing his own

[randomperson123]

Community Vote Round 6 by randomperson123

Boss & CD The Chaosomes: The cards looked good, and the stall deck looked like a good deck based on the little knowledge I have about deckbuilding. Abyss Brawlers: The cards looked good and balanced... at least from my nonexistent knowledge of card balancing, and the deck was explained very well. Artist & DB Abyss Brawlers: I originally chose Gaia's Pride, but then I found out that the art wasn't theirs... so I looked at the art that was best other than that of the Chaosomes, and the trailer made by the Abyss Brawlers was definitely the best-looking one, and the one with the most effort put into it. So Boo to cheaters, and Yay to the Abyss Brawlers who ACTUALLY DID THEIR OWN WORK AND MADE IT LOOK GOOD! The Chaosomes: May not have exactly followed the rules/example, but it's still a great example. And the art is definitely one of the best too. FE League of Shadows: Very appealing design; it was also very engaging and I liked it a lot. Abyss Brawlers: The sarcastic (or whatever word you're supposed to use to describe it) tone was pretty hilarious, and that drew me in. Writer League of Shadows: Great! Gives some lore to the game and wouldn't exasperate players' patience with a very long introduction. Abyss Brawlers: Pretty great! Definitely does a good job at setting up the lore of the game without being too boring or verbose. Bonus League of Shadows: Definitely the best out of all of them! I like the quantity and I also really like the quality of everything! Kudos to you! Abyss Brawlers: Gaia's Pride's submission was pretty good too, but this  inched ahead of that, although Gaia's Pride does come a very close third on this one. I liked how it relates to the whole "Abyss Brawlers" theme. Super Bonus Abyss Brawlers: Actually made their own comic, unlike FHM, and actually made some sense, unlike the comic by LoS. The Chaosomes: same as Abyss Brawlers (FHM just copied from Tokyo Ghoul and LoS made no sense at all, and there were only two others, AB and TC). Also pretty funny too!

Espithel's Frustration	AB: The challenge was an ARTIST challenge. Obviously, FHM forgot that, so AB automatically wins. Besides, the art on FHM's card doesn't look that realistic anyway.
Espithel's Delirium	FHM: The third card in AB's set wasn't mentioned at all by the other cards, so it wouldn't have been made FHM's cards didn't have that problem so they won.
Espithel's Duplicity	AB: FHM didn't finish the task so AB pretty much gets an automatic win on this one.
Ulamog, the Ceaseless NearHundred	FHM: FHM's card seemed slightly more practical than the other card.
Animated Tribute	AB: This was definitely a close one, but I decided to choose AB because they actually took the effort to draw their team members instead of just taking the profile pictures, and they actually added a background and music to it too, which was nice.
Mechanical Underdrive	AB: This one beat the other team's submission because there's actually a reason to upgrade this card other than just a decrease of 1 quanta in cost.
Ascension	TC: I'm choosing this one because they wrote a strategy and explanation of their deck.
Buy one get one free!	TC: Bright, flashy, pleasing to the eye; it's definitely very enticing, and besides, just like they said, it didn't have to be perfectly practical!

[andretimpa]

I noticed you missed the wagers.

[mathman101]

If Abyss wins brawl, I will film myself dancing to nicki minaj.
This is a promise.

We had actually attempted that Dance Off April Fools Bonus. However we did not finish before the deadline.

Here is what we had when deadline ended:

Spoiler for mathman can't dance:

A Toadally Newtral Dance Off Party

Spoiler for Elemental lyrics:

The Elementals won't...
The Elementals won't.....
The Elementals won't play games unless you've got nymphs bud!
An old vet named Root was a Master of Fire;
He became the Grandmaster and fulfilled his desire.
Now he put up a challenge and regrets the decision,
'cause out of the Darkness came a man named Physsion.
And now they play, that, game,
They going at it as they type their names,
PvP matches, they be searching for a duel,
The fire burns him as he runs out of fuel.
They playing Elements!

[JonathanCrazyJ]

I frikkin love you mathman