Forum Brawl #4 - Round 6 (Final)

[AD TienzuStorm]

Nae, so would cards that say they are affected by Nightfall be counted? And again, what about FFQ?

[OldTrees]

Nae, so would cards that say they are affected by Nightfall be counted? And again, what about FFQ?

Cards affected by Nightfall refer to the element of their card not the quanta of their element. So no Skeleton does not get to count Nightfall as  .

[Naesala]

We can still use pens, markers, crayons, etc. to color and add details to a sculpture right?

Yes

How would something like Firefly Queen be counted? As 2 or 3?

We'll count it as three, however creatures that make creatures isn't the most novel idea.

[Fippe94]

For Boss task, do we have to follow the rules in the original task we choose to redraw from, or can we do it in any style/medium we want?

[OldTrees]

How would something like Firefly Queen be counted? As 2 or 3?

We'll count it as three, however creatures that make creatures isn't the most novel idea.

I agree there. FFQ already does the simplest model of that for this task. Most ideas on that track will be FFQ+misc which makes the created part unrelated to the task.

[Naesala]

For Boss task, do we have to follow the rules in the original task we choose to redraw from, or can we do it in any style/medium we want?

Any rules you want.

[Espithel]

How is hybrid quanta treated for the CD task?

[OldTrees]

How is hybrid quanta treated for the CD task?

Hybrid quanta is the ability to pay the cost with quanta type A, quanta type B, or some mixture of both. Seems like it would counts as +2.

[Espithel]

How is hybrid quanta treated for the CD task?

Hybrid quanta is the ability to pay the cost with quanta type A, quanta type B, or some mixture of both. Seems like it would counts as +2.

True. Don't like it though.


Granted, it won't get us votes... Unless someone is an exploitative goithole with it. Which they will be.

[andretimpa]

For the boss task, which of these is what you mean?

Take for example the artist task from round 1, Brawl 3 (make an avatar for your team)

Remake the art, following the same general idea of the original? (in this case remake one of the avatars following the original idea)
Do an entry as if the task was the task this round? (in this case, make an avatar for "Red Stars")
Remake the art, without necessarily following the original? (make an avatar for one of the teams in Brawl 3, even without following the original idea)
All of the above are okay?

[russianspy1234]

How is hybrid quanta treated for the CD task?

Hybrid quanta is the ability to pay the cost with quanta type A, quanta type B, or some mixture of both. Seems like it would counts as +2.

I'll argue that hybrid quanta is it's own +1.  Otherwise, making an  would fit the challenge as it's +12.

[Naesala]

How is hybrid quanta treated for the CD task?

Hybrid quanta is the ability to pay the cost with quanta type A, quanta type B, or some mixture of both. Seems like it would counts as +2.

I'll argue that hybrid quanta is it's own +1.  Otherwise, making an  would fit the challenge as it's +12.

We will let hybrid mana cards in, but we'll allow everyone to vote as they feel for whether it's valid or not. There is no hybrid mana mechanic in game, so this is going fairly far for a card. Unlikely to get my vote, anyways.

For the boss task, which of these is what you mean?

Take for example the artist task from round 1, Brawl 3 (make an avatar for your team)

Remake the art, following the same general idea of the original? (in this case remake one of the avatars following the original idea)
Do an entry as if the task was the task this round? (in this case, make an avatar for "Red Stars")
Remake the art, without necessarily following the original? (make an avatar for one of the teams in Brawl 3, even without following the original idea)
All of the above are okay?

Answer 1 is what was intended