| Non Brawler Vote | Round 6 | by OldTrees |
|
| Boss | *** | *** | | Artist | *** | *** | | CD & DB | Meaning of Life | Frostbite Borealis | | FE | *** | *** | | OT & Writer | *** | *** | | BONUS | *** | *** | | SUPER BONUS | *** | *** | | Challenge "A" | Red Stars | n/a | | Challenge "B" | Ragnarok | n/a | | Challenge "C" | Meaning of Life | n/a |
|
Card Designer/Deckbuilder
I don't like forced Trios. As such I didn't like any of the solutions the Card Designers came up with since they were restrained in that aspect. Ragnarok's did not qualify in my opinion. Red Stars's does qualify but the resulting card does not want to be used as such.
So the options we have are:
3 types of costs
An ability that changes
Generate quanta
Of these Gravy's was a bit lazy (both Fireflies merged as a Life Permanent).
All in all it was a good showing for such a task.
Challenges:
-A-
Red Stars wins this one hands down in my opinion. Both were good topics and good insights, but TheElkSpeaks chose a more advanced topic than KirbyLover. Still, I would like to stress that these were both very good. I hope both of them take the time to go more in depth on their topics and perhaps other topics as well.
-B-
A moderately overpowered card using Mirror pseudoquanta
vs
A slightly overpowered card using a
/
hybrid cost. However it does not fit the
side of the hybrid(since a hybrid card needs to make sense as a mono card in each element not a combination like in the case of a duo card) and thus is not appropriate for a
/
hybrid.
-C-
MoL: "Sacrifice" is a word that has meaning in EtG. You would want to change the ability name to something else.
Frostbite: Your late entry is missing its notes as a result of it being late. This makes it hard to guess at the intended 3rd element.
