Forum Brawl #3 - Suggestions and Feedback

[CrockettRocket]

Well, it was a suggestion in the sense the other team mates can do his job. But where the ferns in standings are behind I was suggesting that the substitute goes to their team. :b I cant remember how cuckoo is doing but if everything is already handled then ok. :/

[andretimpa]

Well, it was a suggestion in the sense the other team mates can do his job. But where the ferns in standings are behind I was suggesting that the substitute goes to their team. :b I cant remember how cuckoo is doing but if everything is already handled then ok. :/

I think he's team mates would have noticed by now.

[CrockettRocket]

Yeah, but the usefulness of the post still stands; I stated the official date he quit.

[theelkspeaks]

A thought just occurred to me in light of the discussion on voting bias based on teams - would it be possible, at least for those tasks that don't revolve around a team name/boss/membership to list the submissions with an alternate identifier (A, B, C, D, E instead of team names, and vote based on those letters)?  Teams would still know which was theirs and likely give that one one of their two votes, but it could reduce some of the bias involved when deciding which opposing team to give the second vote to and/or nonbrawlers giving votes.

[dark ripper]

A thought just occurred to me in light of the discussion on voting bias based on teams - would it be possible, at least for those tasks that don't revolve around a team name/boss/membership to list the submissions with an alternate identifier (A, B, C, D, E instead of team names, and vote based on those letters)?  Teams would still know which was theirs and likely give that one one of their two votes, but it could reduce some of the bias involved when deciding which opposing team to give the second vote to and/or nonbrawlers giving votes.

I really dont know why this isnt a thing. Really, I mean, team A is 1st and 1 round remaining, well its only natural that other teams wont vote that team. Its natural team spirit. At least for 6th round do this.

[andretimpa]

It was this way in Brawl 1. The main problem is that it is still too easy to tell who made what in some tasks (artist, writer, FE and OT are particularly troublesome). It was decided that the flexibility of using team names and things like that outweighted this "anonimity". The only real way of removing this type of bias is not to show the results until the end imo.

Also, with hidden wagers sharp shooting becomes a dangerous game.

[dawn to dusk]

at the end of brawl, can we have some special statistics thing? like most voted submission, best card designer/designers, etc

[OldTrees]

at the end of brawl, can we have some special statistics thing? like most voted submission, best card designer/designers, etc

What metric would you like?
Most (points earned)?
Most (points earned - auction cost)?
Most (places * average points per place [7/6, 14/6, 23/6, 34/6, 45/6, 56/6])?
Etc?

[CrockettRocket]

For me personally points earned-auction cost.

[Fippe94]

For me personally: just the best average place.

[Naesala]

Oh dear >.> I don't know if I could do most total votes. I could do overall best placing? To do most total votes I'd have to go through every thread and count the votes again >.>

I can try and come up with some statistics though.

[SpikeSpiegel]

Oh dear >.> I don't know if I could do most total votes. I could do overall best placing? To do most total votes I'd have to go through every thread and count the votes again >.>

I can try and come up with some statistics though.

Online calculator