Forum Brawl #3 - Suggestions and Feedback

[Naesala]

Reputation and reputation power are not the same

(Also, move this somewhere else please, this is irrelevant to the thread)

[OldTrees]

(Also, move this somewhere else please, this is irrelevant to the thread)

Sorry about that.



Any other stats desired?

[CrockettRocket]

Most points earned in a single round for each person, or most points earned in a single round for the greatest person in the team or most points earned in a single round for each round.

[OldTrees]

Most points earned in a single round for each person, or most points earned in a single round for the greatest person in the team or most points earned in a single round for each round.

Round 1-5 card designer stats (I will include round 6 later since I do not time travel)

Name	Team	Round with their personal highest place	Round with their personal most points earned*
eljoemo	Whispers in the Dark	1st, 2nd & 5th(1st place)	5th(12)
Rutarete	Death Dost Dominate	3rd & 4th(2nd place)	4th(10)
SpikeSpiegel	Divine Light	5th(2nd place)	5th(10)
Terroking	Silver Ferns	4th(1st place)	4th(10)
russianspy1234	The Cuckoo's Nest	3rd(1st place)	3rd(8 )

*"Round with the most points earned" is certain to change for at least 2 card designers when round 6 is included


"most points earned in a single round for each round" = 1st place that round (see previous stat post)

[CrockettRocket]

Go eljoe for getting the most points earned in any round for any person.

@old trees, do you think it'd be too much work to include everyone's most points earned in a single round and which round? I know thats a lot of work, and I appreciate the work you've already done, but that's what I'm mostly interested in seeing.

[OldTrees]

Go eljoe for getting the most points earned in any round for any person.

@old trees, do you think it'd be too much work to include everyone's most points earned in a single round and which round? I know thats a lot of work, and I appreciate the work you've already done, but that's what I'm mostly interested in seeing.

eljoe only earned the most points in a round in the Card Design task. (By placing 1st most recently) Since most points in a round is rather trivial I decided to do which round they made more points than their other rounds. Again the point system rewards later rounds more but at least some more information is gained.

I can extend these stats to the other roles. I will wait until the round 6 votes are all collected(including Chapuz's). However it does not take much time (less than 5 minutes per each of these posts) so others might beat me to it.

[CrockettRocket]

Only ones I can think who'd try that would be the BMs.. which is rather pointless when we have an active volunteer.

How does the point system award higher in latter rounds?

[OldTrees]

Only ones I can think who'd try that would be the BMs.. which is rather pointless when we have an active volunteer.

How does the point system award higher in latter rounds?

Place ~> Round v	6th	5th	4th	3rd	2nd	1st
Round 1	1	1	2	3	4	5
Round 2	1	1	3	4	5	6
Round 3	1	2	3	5	6	8
Round 4	1	3	4	6	8	10
Round 5	1	3	5	7	10	12
Round 6	2	4	6	9	12	15

Each place in Round 6 rewards greater than or equal to the rewards of Rounds 2 & 3 combined. This is intended to keep the chance of a comeback.

[rob77dp]

The 6th round points being higher also discourages a team in the lead from 'mailing it in' while also encouraging trailing teams to 'stick it out'.  Think of ot like how Family Feud does it (single, double, and triple-point rounds - in the show's case the triple-round winning team almost always advances to the bonus/final round.

[MyNameIsJoey]

Personally, I dislike Challenges.

1- They add workload. Some of us don't necessarly have the time to do both their task and challenges. Brawl is made for fun, not to become a chore.
2- Being public, unlike wagers, they get prone to strategic voting, which is something we want to avoid in stuff like brawl.

[OldTrees]

Personally, I dislike Challenges.

1- They add workload. Some of us don't necessarly have the time to do both their task and challenges. Brawl is made for fun, not to become a chore.
2- Being public, unlike wagers, they get prone to strategic voting, which is something we want to avoid in stuff like brawl.

I like the concept of challenges in that it is the fellow brawlers creating a fun mini task. For instance one card designer could challenge another to "Let's each create a new quanta generator card idea and then see which idea was better!"
They are some issues with their implementation in Brawl but I do not have any solutions for the issues I saw in Brawl 2.
Issue 1: Since I was in the leading team, the tactical move was to play it safe and not issue challenges. (I regret this plan)
Issue 2: Since I was a highest value Card Designer in Brawl 2(although not the highest added value IIRC), none of the other Card Designers tried to challenge me.

[eljoemo]

Could we possibly get a Team Member Feedback thread, where we can say stuff about how we felt our team / members did. Kinda like, "eljoemo was great, get this guy on your team next Brawl!" or "eljoemo was hard to work with and we had to cover his tasks most of the time." Just so that we can ensure good brawlers get the appreciation they deserve and Boss can chose better for next Brawl. Kinda like this thread but for Brawl not War.