WITD (Round 4 voting)

[Naesala]

Note you will have until 1 daybefore Round 5's tasks are due which, at the moment, is up in the air.

[MyNameIsJoey]

Votes

Boss task : Silver Ferns
artist : cuckoo's nest
Deckbuilder : Divine Light
Card design : I'm a bit disappointed with all tasks there. Not that they aren't good, but I'm expecting a bit more. Vote goes to Death Dost Dominate
Forum Expert : I would love for a battle subforum to bring battle back alive. Sadly, this is wishful thinking. Well you're lucky I'm an Idealist, because Silver Ferns still get my vote.
Writer : Cuckoo's nest. While we don't see an NPC bazaar keeper, it was fun, and makes us imagine there is one. Creativity bringing us to the deepest of ourselves. Great job.
Bonus task : Here again I'm a bit disappointed. Is there nothing more that can be added to this game at all? Vote goes for Cuckoo's.
Challenge ( SF vs Cuckoo's ) : My vote goes for cuckoo's. I personally cannot see myself using the catapult calculator when I already know the formula.

This. And add votes for WITD ina ll categories ( except the challenge of SF vs cuckoo, obviously )

[dark ripper]

Boss: WITD, Ferns
Artist: WITD, Cuckoo
Deckbuilder: WITD, Light
Card Designer: WITD, DDD
Forum Expert: WITD, Ferns
Writer: Cuckoo

Bonus: Ferns

Challenge 1: Cuckoo

Challenge 2: WITD Invalid vote. Cannot just vote for self (Yes, this means you essentially can't vote on a challenge you're team is in unless you're conceeding the other team is better.)

Just realised, Joey we have almost the same votes xD lol!

[MegroN]

Boss: WITD, DL
Artist: WITD, Cuckoo
Deckbuilder: WITD, DL
Card Designer: WITD, SF
Forum Expert: WITD, SF
Writer: WITD, Cuckoo (Nice)

Challenge 1: Cuckoo

Challenge 2: WITD Invalid vote (see above)

[eljoemo]

Boss: WITD, DL
Artist: WITD, CN
Deck: WITD, CN
CD: WITD, DDD
FE: WITD, DL
Writer: WITD, DL
Challenge 1 (CN vs SF): CN
Challenge 2 (WITD vs CN): WITD Invalid vote (see above)

[MyNameIsJoey]

If i am not obligated to vote for an enemy team for challenge 2 then vote goes for us. Meg's drawing is truely awesome.

[theelkspeaks]

Boss: Ferns and Whispers in the Dark.  Ferns have a pretty cool game there, and I'd actually like to see it become a real forum game.

Artist: DDD and Whispers.  DDD looks the most Baroque-like to me, and it's kinda a cool twist on the art as well.

Deckbuilding: Cuckoo's and Whispers.  Cuckoo's actually feels like a deck I'd be willing to play, and it fits its theme pretty well too.

Card Design: Whispers and Ferns.  Most of the cards have too-un-EtG like mechanics for me, but the Ferns' pair seems pretty cool.

Forum Expert: Whispers and Divine Light - I really dislike the Promotion and Hell ideas, and I feel like a subforum just for Battle would be a little too much.

Writer: Whispers and DDD - I actually really like what they did with Morte, short but sweet and pretty effective!

Challenge 1: Cuckoo's, because the catapult tool is useless.

Challenge 2: Whispers, because oh my god, MegroN is an amazing artist even more than usual! Invalid vote (see above)

[Naesala]

Voting Closed