Brawl #3 - Survey

[Naesala]

Anyone is free to answer any or all of these questions, the information will be helpful!

How did you feel about the auctions via googledocs (especially bosses)?
How did you feel about standings via googledocs?
How much did you use your secret section? Did you like having a secret section?
How good/bad was the workload for Brawl?
How much time did you spend actually interacting with your team?
How much did you enjoy Brawl?
Will you participate in Brawl #4? (This isn't a promise ^_^)

And of course, additional thoughts are welcome, but please keep everything to the appropriate threads (Suggestions in the suggestion thread, Apprciation in it's, etc.)

[dawn to dusk]

Anyone is free to answer any or all of these questions, the information will be helpful!

How did you feel about the auctions via googledocs (especially bosses)? i didnt follow it too much, i just saw who bid on me and yea. i dont have anything to compare to though... all in all, it was good
How did you feel about standings via googledocs? again, nothing to compare to. though the formatting was good.
How much did you use your secret section? Did you like having a secret section? well, see our secret section ^^ it was great to have one and have all submissions in one neat little thread though
How good/bad was the workload for Brawl? it was pretty perfect for me, while on a computer, check in and see the titan pad, giving suggestions where i deem necessary, while off, work on my task.
How much time did you spend actually interacting with your team? pretty much all of it
How much did you enjoy Brawl? i enjoyed it quite a bit, a great non-pvp event and im sad not more people joined...
Will you participate in Brawl #4? (This isn't a promise ^_^) most likely, though ill use a different role if possible ^^ i liked being writer, though the tasks were definitely not what i was expecting

And of course, additional thoughts are welcome, but please keep everything to the appropriate threads (Suggestions in the suggestion thread, Apprciation in it's, etc.)

green is my answers

[dark ripper]

The only thing I can say for sure is that I wont join Brawl #4 unless the voting system changes. With forum inactivity, brawlers' voting favours strategic voting. I didnt like that. It has been suggested that voting can be private(only private) so that noone knows which team is first. That would help a lot. About the tasks, I have a bitter taste cause I worked( alll DBs) only once with another role, and I didnt like the task on round 3. I spent quite a long time in our pad working with my team(something that i shouldnt do due to my finals ). I have mixed feelings about Brawl in general; I met some wonderful guys who I worked with and my rivals made the event even more  interesting but inactivity made it kinda dull.

[andretimpa]

How did you feel about the auctions via googledocs (especially bosses)?

I thought it was a good way of keeping everything in just one place, but it's mostly useful for the bosses.

How did you feel about standings via googledocs?

Much useful and prevented the unnending summation errors from last Brawl.

How much did you use your secret section? Did you like having a secret section?

Just for voting. The voting system it allows is the best part of it imo.

How good/bad was the workload for Brawl?

Considering my tasks only it was good. Considering the inactivity in my team, that meant doing around 3 tasks in the last rounds, it was tough (I only managed it because of some holidays giving me extra time away from work)

How much time did you spend actually interacting with your team?

The team dynamics settled on brainstorming on the first day in the pad, leaving random feedback from them on and coming together in the last 2 days to cover the tasks that were still missing. So I'd say 40% of the time.

How much did you enjoy Brawl?

This Brawl was much better than the last one. I'm still not convinced of claims about strategic voting and even if there was strategic voting it was nowhere as bad as last Brawl. Truth is most of the teams were pretty balanced, and I'd say that most of us would deserve to win.

Will you participate in Brawl #4? (This isn't a promise ^_^)

Depends more on how crazy life will be at the time. But I'm pending towards yes.

[OldTrees]

Will you participate in Brawl #4? (This isn't a promise ^_^)
Time willing. So, likely.

[Calambar]

Anyone is free to answer any or all of these questions, the information will be helpful!

How did you feel about the auctions via googledocs (especially bosses)?
i didnt follow it too much, i just saw who bid on me and yea. i dont have anything to compare to though... all in all, it was good
How did you feel about standings via googledocs?
again, nothing to compare to. though the formatting was good.
How much did you use your secret section? Did you like having a secret section?
well, see our secret section ^^ it was great to have one and have all submissions in one neat little thread though
How good/bad was the workload for Brawl?
Quite good and even, used mostly titan for that. Yet I found some tasks too time-consuming for a just a week... Considering RL stuff too ;]
How much time did you spend actually interacting with your team?
pretty much all of it
How much did you enjoy Brawl?
i enjoyed it quite a bit, a great non-pvp event and im sad not more people joined...
Will you participate in Brawl #4? (This isn't a promise ^_^)
depends on time, I'm married now, so... we will see. But I wonder.. Will EtG still exist in one year? ... I hope so... Additionally, I don't like the voting system very much, as you know...

green is my answers


I used mostly dawn's answer, I changed only a little there, but all the rest is true for me too. It was convenient dawn, thanks ^^

[andretimpa]

Will you participate in Brawl #4? (This isn't a promise ^_^)
Time willing. So, likely.

DUN DUN DUN

[Kakerlake]

Anyone is free to answer any or all of these questions, the information will be helpful!

Yay, well if it's free, I'll take it :3

How did you feel about the auctions via googledocs (especially bosses)?

I liked it way better than the classic way to vote. Guess it's totally worth it to put more effort into this kind of voting system.

How did you feel about standings via googledocs?

Yay, more googledocs <3
Would be nice to have one more brawlmaster who is only responsible for updating googledocs and doing statistics there. Having it done by someone who hardly can programm a function didn't seem right (no offense Nae)

How much did you use your secret section? Did you like having a secret section?

Hardly used it, for voting it served its purpose.
We're using a pad as a main communication platform, which was just perfect.

How good/bad was the workload for Brawl?

Pretty badly balanced IMO.
In some rounds, one guy had to work on multiple tasks, even though he wasn't officially part of the task.
Overall the ammount of work seemed all right tough.

How much time did you spend actually interacting with your team?

Sometimes I was testing a Deck by myself. Sometimes I was writing something alone.
Anything else was pretty much done in the team.

How much did you enjoy Brawl?

Was fun! I even found out that I'm apparantly a quite decent writer =)

Will you participate in Brawl #4? (This isn't a promise ^_^)

Will there be a Brawl #4?
I can only promise to consider the possibility of joining.

And of course, additional thoughts are welcome, but please keep everything to the appropriate threads (Suggestions in the suggestion thread, Apprciation in it's, etc.)

No. I'll write all my ideas here. muahahaa!
...
..
.
but I don't have any right now.

[Zawadx]

How did you feel about the auctions via googledocs (especially bosses)?

I liked how everything was in one place, though I missed the grandness of bidding in their respective threads. Easier for Bosses though.

How did you feel about standings via googledocs?

Neat. Would've prefered if Wagers and Challenges went to their proper roles though. (just personal preference here)

How much did you use your secret section? Did you like having a secret section?

We used it for formatting and organizing mostly. And for voting, voting was nice.

How good/bad was the workload for Brawl?

Perfect. Less enough to let me slack for most of the time, and more than enough to put a pressure.

How much time did you spend actually interacting with your team?

We did have our fair share of interaction. Of course by Round 3 or 4 we had all gotten into a structure, so we'd brainstorm our ideas in the early rounds and then do all the work on the last day, and then panic before deadline because of Asy.

How much did you enjoy Brawl?

Tremendously. 17.5/10 would do this again.

Will you participate in Brawl #4? (This isn't a promise ^_^)

See the previous answer.

[Skotadi Phobos]

Anyone is free to answer any or all of these questions, the information will be helpful!

How did you feel about the auctions via googledocs (especially bosses)? Indifferent
How did you feel about standings via googledocs? Indifferent
How much did you use your secret section? Did you like having a secret section? The secret section was very useful, I'm glad to have had it.
How good/bad was the workload for Brawl? Videos were stressful because I have no experience with such things, but I usually just traded tasks with someone who does.
How much time did you spend actually interacting with your team? A decent amount of time, but not as much as I'd have liked.
How much did you enjoy Brawl? How much do you enjoy breathing?
Will you participate in Brawl #4? (This isn't a promise ^_^) Unless it'll take place over the summer, of course I will.

And of course, additional thoughts are welcome, but please keep everything to the appropriate threads (Suggestions in the suggestion thread, Apprciation in it's, etc.)

[MyNameIsJoey]

Anyone is free to answer any or all of these questions, the information will be helpful!

1.How did you feel about the auctions via googledocs (especially bosses)?
2.How did you feel about standings via googledocs?
3.How much did you use your secret section? Did you like having a secret section?
4.How good/bad was the workload for Brawl?
5.How much time did you spend actually interacting with your team?
6.How much did you enjoy Brawl?
7.Will you participate in Brawl #4? (This isn't a promise ^_^)

And of course, additional thoughts are welcome, but please keep everything to the appropriate threads (Suggestions in the suggestion thread, Apprciation in it's, etc.)

1. It was not bad, but I prefer to good old method to yell in yellow in the threads.
2. Standings were great. Nothing to say about it.
3. Secret section is secret section. I personally put the link to our pad in there, in case someone lost the link, so I guess that's important, but really we talked more in PM and pad. What -could- be used is a bit like war having submissions be sent on section instead of PM so that your box don't fill up.
4. I think it was fine. Except for challenges, but I've complained about that already in S&F.
5. About as much time I actually spend on elements.
6. Very much. Yeah I've had my ups and downs, mostly downs in the last rounds, but in general, it was an awesome experience.
7. Probably will, but not as a boss. I want to try new stuff

[SpikeSpiegel]

How did you feel about standings via googledocs?
I love googledocs, so all fine to me!

How much did you use your secret section? Did you like having a secret section?
Used almost every rounds. Very useful.

How good/bad was the workload for Brawl?
It was nice. Maybe too much related to teams names, but after all, it was cool.

How much time did you spend actually interacting with your team?
Lot of time. Brawl was a nice opportunity to know more and better some people

How much did you enjoy Brawl?
Very much!

Will you participate in Brawl #4? (This isn't a promise ^_^)
I hope so!

What do you think about Brawlmasters?
BM's did an amazing job, this community is lucky to have them!