Brawl #2 - Round 6 [Voting Phase]

[ARTHANASIOS]

Ok so i am a little late to the POed party here but i was on vacation (totally didnt reschedule my vacation just so i wouldnt miss a chunk of brawl    ) and now i want to weight in.  first, i would like to ask for someone who voted for entropy over my card in the challenge to explain why... because as far as i can tell, my card is objectively better... and thats not something i would say about almost any other card round/contest, including the one we won. i mean, their card didnt even follow the rules of the card type by saying it doesn't stack (and even quoted the part where they should stack from my rules in round 5.) and then there is the fact that the card type they created was IMO the best one from round 5 (though voters liked other cards better, they clearly liked their card type better than mine.) for me to lose the challenge by such a wide margin... i would just like to know if there was something that happened that wasnt vote tampering, because if there was, then something is clearly wrong with my card design philosophy that i need to correct.

card designer task: im fairly ok with losing this one, i did stretch the theme a bit...

i'm not gonna complain about the bonus task, i actually foresaw the possibility of us being penalized by voters for creating something that wasnt a traditional snapshot (picture) even though it does technically fit the definition of one.


might comment on other tasks and respond to posts after a good nights sleep. need a vacation after my vacation...

I have voted for voting for your idea, dear Russian Spy, and here is a screenshot (cause no one is going to believe me otherwise):

Spoiler for Hidden:

However, Mutagen offered nothing new to the game other than another Mutation effect (I love mutations, so I've voted for it) and we already have Fallen Elf | Fallen Druid and Mutation | Improved Mutation, let aside Fate Egg's "Hatch" and Skeleton's "Undead" have an effect pretty similar to mutation.

On the other hand, Sap offered an attack decrease ability which can also become negative, offering a completely new effect to the game and adding an alternative way to obtain an Antimatter-like effect. The fact they say it doesn't stack it is an exception to the general rule in order to prevent Sap from becoming OP. Just my 2 .

[OldTrees]

first, i would like to ask for someone who voted for entropy over my card in the challenge to explain why... because as far as i can tell, my card is objectively better... and thats not something i would say about almost any other card round/contest, including the one we won. i mean, their card didnt even follow the rules of the card type by saying it doesn't stack (and even quoted the part where they should stack from my rules in round 5.) and then there is the fact that the card type they created was IMO the best one from round 5 (though voters liked other cards better, they clearly liked their card type better than mine.) for me to lose the challenge by such a wide margin... i would just like to know if there was something that happened that wasnt vote tampering, because if there was, then something is clearly wrong with my card design philosophy that i need to correct.

I voted for Mutagen. However I can see a few reasons some might have liked Sap better.
1) We already have ways to mutate. However we have much fewer ways to decrease attack relative to the number of theoretical variations.
2) It is hard to judge the balance of these new card types. Mutagen appears more powerful than Sap. Since people are more adverse to OP than to UP, this might have swayed a few votes.
3) Some may have preferred the Creeper card type over the Essence card type. (This should not have influenced the vote but it might have)

[justaburd]

If you look at entropy's FE task, it's essentially copy-pasted from the mentor system. Credit was given.

I don't like the voting.

[Anarook]

If you look at entropy's FE task, it's essentially copy-pasted from the mentor system. Credit was given.

I don't like the voting.

 
Well then...