Mm.. it saddens me when I see vets trashing newcomers. I intend to give many of them a chance to join War with me. Another side of the coin with the auction is, however, this: when a player wants to be in a team and a General wants them on that team, wouldn't it make sense to let that happen? War is a game within a game: it's all for fun. If someone wants to join a team they know they'll have fun in, I think they should be allowed to without other Generals making them pay more for them or even take them.
Some enjoy this game of manipulation and think it's a part of War. Yes, it seems it's intended thus. It makes sense not to disallow one to use manipulation in something as ruthless as a conceptual war. Still, I think fun should come before that. I've made a total of one deal thus far, and that's because the two players involved want to be on a specific team and the Generals want them. It's more fun for all parties. I won't make deals for players I intend to buy for their skill, though. That includes Val.
Regardless, it's a good move to go Slave instead. Less drama overall. I don't want any of that.