EvaRia (Aether)

[Annele]

Which means they are required to make a legal bid, correct??

All I know is that you DID make a legal bid, and therefore are not allowed to remove it.

[majofa]

In every War previous, Generals had to follow up an illegal bid with a legal one... WMs gave no indication that this was changed... I'm allowed to make as many illegal bids as I want?

[MyNameIsJoey]

In every War previous, Generals had to follow up an illegal bid with a legal one... WMs gave no indication that this was changed... I'm allowed to make as many illegal bids as I want?

But is this written in the current's war rules?

[mesaprotector]

Honestly I think we should just let majofa retract his bid. It was a simple misunderstanding and one any of us could have made.

[deuce22]

I remember Higs getting a penalty for each bid she posted in the wrong color...

IMO, the 3-card bid should stand because that is what the rules state. Your team already costs so much, what's 1 extra card?

[majofa]

But an illegal bid getting removed... is still a bid being removed.

[Vangelios]

majofa, admit that you erred, worth more than the removal of bids.

[majofa]

I did error when I made an illegal bid, but I was just trying to follow the rules in following it up with a legal bid.

...but I guess since everyone wants it this way.... everyone else who made an illegal bid and had it removed will now be given a penalty as per the rules.

[deuce22]

But there were some illegal bids which people did not post a "legal bid" afterwards...

But I'm also ok with illegal bids receiving a penalty too since I didn't make an illegal bid

[Jenkar]

In every War previous, Generals had to follow up an illegal bid with a legal one... WMs gave no indication that this was changed... I'm allowed to make as many illegal bids as I want?

False : http://elementscommunity.org/forum/index.php/topic,38540.msg480385.html#msg480385 <= example.
You are not allowed to retract your bid. Hence, the current highest bid on EvaRia is 3, by .

You are allowed to try our patience, but there are things wise men (and women) do not do.

But an illegal bid getting removed... is still a bid being removed.

Only if it's the general himself who removes his own illegal bid. As in remove the post. Making an illegal by accident is not penalized. (making them on purpose will be)


Please, everyone, let's get this thread back to posting bids and backstabbing Eva.

[Vangelios]

But the rule was created  to apply, it is not?
happens, I wanted to participate in the weekly tournament on the 29th, went missing 3 min to start and I was not allowed, all the tournaments that I attended had player arriving after 15 min and was accepted, but I do not, and I had to accept naturally

[majofa]

Yay for being punished for trying to follow the rules...