Water Golem | Ice Golem

[Bloodshadow]

I doubt that this card will make it in-game otherwise.

I don't expect this card to make it in-game ever.

If it does, it will probably get changed that way.

That's Zanz's choice, not mine.

No other cards are like that.

Then this is the first.

I highly doubt any will become that way.

Again, let this be the first.

Upgrading cards with unupped and cheap cards? No. Just, no.

Why not? That's your personal opinion which I don't share.

Enough reasons for ya? :|

No.

[Glitch]

I love the concept of this card.  The upgrade speeds your deck up by about half a turn, which is fair.  Plus, it's an easy mono-water way of getting a non-rare squid.  This card definitely deserves it's spot in the armory.

[Kael Hate]

Beofre this goes any further. This is Bloodshadows idea and you are within your rights to ask him why or suggest a change to the idea to improve it but there is no requirement for him to accept that advice or change the card in anyway. This card has been voted to this level based on this version as is and with a mechanic that allows it to change between upped and basic. Zanz may choose to use it in this manner or change it to suit his whim or not use it at all. Ideas are good or bad, favourable or not, but never wrong. Please be more respectful of those that have submitted ideas and if you don't like them don't vote for them.

[Zac33333]

Whatever, thats just what I think. Besides, look at pheonix. It was kinda like this, but it got split into 2 cards.

[DeathFlamer]

is there any reason for upgrading?

[Kael Hate]

is there any reason for upgrading?

Because it comes into play with a double life where the basic version just dies.

[Bloodshadow]

is there any reason for upgrading?

You no longer need an extra Freeze to turn Water Golem into Ice Golem. And, what Kael said.

[nilsieboy]

i realy love this idea and the art is great to

[snugglebunny]

Question and or suggestion - Since Ice Golem is Frozen* would shockwave kill it instantly? and thus turn it back to water?  If not, it should. since that is the Rule of shockwave.

And Health aside, say for instance if it was buffed up in some way to hps higher then shockwaves normal damage.

[Bloodshadow]

Question and or suggestion - Since Ice Golem is Frozen* would shockwave kill it instantly? and thus turn it back to water?  If not, it should. since that is the Rule of shockwave.

Read the first post again. When you turn Water Golem into Ice Golem, Ice Golem ISN'T frozen.

[Kuroaitou]

The only concern I have about this card...

I love the concept of this card.  The upgrade speeds your deck up by about half a turn, which is fair.  Plus, it's an easy mono-water way of getting a non-rare squid.  This card definitely deserves it's spot in the armory.

Doesn't this card make Arctic Squid a little... useless?

The only benefit that Arctic Squid has over Ice Golem is that it can't be killed by using its own ability. HOWEVER, having multiple Ice Golems out would pretty much allow you to 'refreeze' golems as needed to give you the required CC. It's a one-many army capable of CC'ing the crap out of everything it sees, provided enough  quanta and assuming your opponent isn't stacking up on Rain of Fire or other nasty damage spells.

Aside from making the Squid less desired, I've come full circle to understand the strength of this card. Nice idea nonetheless.

[KorabanVII]

It's pretty good, though not one of my favorites of your ideas. I don't really like the fact that it can freeze stuff. I liked my version of "Ice Golem" better.
The art for the Water Golem looks kind of cute.