Sunrise | Morning Sun

[ItzSean]

Hmmm... Sounds good. Two turns it is.

[teffy]

I don´t really like this card, because Nightfall has the same effect, and inventing the same card twice is not good game design

How should this card and Nightfall/Eclipse cancel each other out?

The easiest solution is, that, as long as  Nightfall/Eclipse is in play, Sunrise can´t be played , and when Sunrise comes first, Nightfall/Eclipse can´t be played.

[ItzSean]

I don´t really like this card, because Nightfall has the same effect, and inventing the same card twice is not good game design

Since when does this give +1(2 in the case of eclipse)/+1 to all darkness and death creatures..?

How should this card and Nightfall/Eclipse cancel each other out?

The easiest solution is, that, as long as  Nightfall/Eclipse is in play, Sunrise can´t be played , and when Sunrise comes first, Nightfall/Eclipse can´t be played.

Wouldn't that make it quite OP? I like it the way it is, but I also like the idea of them "battling it out".

Edit: I reset the poll because of a change in one of the options. Vote away!

[Avenger]

It should destroy all eclipse on the field (protected too).
Eclipses should also destroy this one.

[evermore414]

I had a very similar idea last night.  Mine would have affected all life/light creatures though.  I don't think this would be OP for life rush decks since you couldn't guarantee drawing the card early without adding multiples to your deck.  And adding multiples of this card to your deck would greatly dilute a rush deck since playing a second card does nothing extra.  Another argument for the upgraded version being balanced with life rush decks is that this would be +1|+2 whereas Eclipse is +2|+1 and health is not as valuable as attack.  Also balancing it for life rushes is that there is no synergy with Adrenaline since adding Adrenaline on a 4 attack frog actually does less damage than with a 3 attack frog.

I think this is how Nightfall vs. Sunrise should work.  When Sunrise is played any Nightfalls already in play are destroyed and all death/darkness creatures are stunned for one turn.  When Nightfall is played any Sunrises already in play are destroyed and all light/life (maybe not life with your version of the card) are stunned for one round.  This would make for some epic back and forth play if two decks using these cards ran into each other.

Great card idea!