...so my precious flying weapons won't have their abilities revoked? Okay, back to complaining about how this shield counters too many decks...
What about Fire Shield/Thorn Carapace screwing over anyone who has immortalized/quinted creatures? Or how Hope can demolish any deck without sufficient creature control? Or Diamond Shield nearly ruining any rush deck?
A lot of shields in the game can counter some pretty intense decks and decks that run along similar lines (rush decks/creature spam, massive spell damage, hard-hitters, high HP, etc.). Wings is still in its balancing phase now, but from what I see it, as long as there are at least 2-3 different ways to counter the shield using creatures, spells, and permanents, then I'm going to say that
deserves a strong shield to help itself out, considering its lack of popularity, diversity, and strength as a mono/duo splash element.
Side note: Thank god Deja Vu's (and Scarabs) can bypass this shield. I would have been astonished at the idea that a 'concept-creature' (Deja Vu) wouldn't be able to break through the 3rd dimension (height) to reach the enemy elemental player. XD Thanks again Zanz for the clarification.