How do you rate decks that beat you ?

[Provolone]

So, do you rate reasonable the decks that defeat you in arena ?
I mean, you give thumbs down for the decks that are common sense (like mono aether and GotP/Nightmare) or you give thumbs down to the decks that annoys you even know its a valid deck idea?
Just curiosity =}

[Jappert]

Instant Thumbs Down:
- Mono (basic ones)
- Oraclebows (basic ones)
- Immorush
- Ghostmare
- Death rushes
- Poisonrush with SoSa
- Mono (basic ones)

Stuff like that.

Thumbs up:
- Original deckbuilding
- Fun Decks
- Strong inventive decks

[xsindomanx]

I usually just thumb down when there are really uncreative decks like: cremation lava rush, graboid, mono aether, and that sort of stuff. But if I sometimes see a deck that I simply really hate and would never use as a nice person, I might also thumb that down

EDIT: People still use oraclebows? x-x

[Djhopper :)]

I only vote down all the "same old" stuff that's already been posted. Or if I get really pissed off at a deck!

[Picheleiro]

Instant Thumbs Down:
- Mono (basic ones)
- Oraclebows (basic ones) I really dont know how to see if a deck its a basic Oraclebow
- Immorush
- Ghostmare THIS.
- Death rushes (basic ones)
- Poisonrush with SoSa
- Mono (basic ones)

This. Copy paste decks.

[rickerd]

Thumb down for:
- decks that are just stupid (can't use oracle card)
-  , & rush
-  stall
-  & diving sh*t
- Fg remakes
- most bows

[Djhopper :)]

Instant Thumbs Down:
- Mono (basic ones)
- Oraclebows (basic ones) I really dont know how to see if a deck its a basic Oraclebow
- Immorush
- Ghostmare THIS.
- Death rushes (basic ones)
- Poisonrush with SoSa
- Mono (basic ones)

This. Copy paste decks.

You allow immorushes?

[Picheleiro]

It depends on the immorush. If the term talks about to use Immo to make an aggro deck, I dontsee it bad.

If Im wrong and it talk about Freecreature+Immo+Golem/BigPhoenix+"Twoelementscreatures" and a pair of deflagrations, no. Its a copypaste deck.

[willng3]

Thumbs down:
-Dead Oracle cards
-Firestalls
-Ghostmares
-Water/Death Poison duos
-Mono Aether
-Antagon Graboid Rainbow duplicates
-Mono Fire rushes (with or without CC, I see them as the same really)
-Discord/BH (depends on what else is thrown in though)
-Shrieker rushes
-Anything that duplicates a False God or a False God killer
-SoSa spam decks

 The list is much longer than this; I'm pretty picky with what I consider original.

Thumbs up:
-Unusual combo decks
-Life decks (I can't imagine why)
-Decks which make good use of a rather useless Oracle Card.

I'm really not bothered by decks which are frustratingly difficult to beat so long as they're original.

Incidentally I'm guilty of putting up unoriginal decks from time to time simply because I enjoy seeing how well they do for myself once - and only once.

[Brontos]

If I'm surprised by a card or a combo, thumbs up. If I smile during the fight, thumbs up.
If not, thumbs down. If I'm pissed, thumbs down (ghostmare are a nearly garanteed down).  8)

[Calindu]

Thumbs down:
-Speedbows with cards splashed in.
-Ghostmare(Unless the card is nightmare)
-Firestall, even with fire bolt/RoF you can make a stall faster and you have lots of combos with rage potion
-SoSa spam decks, seriously, you lock them down the loss by deck-out?
-Mono aether
-Dead marks just for SoG bonus
-Oraclebows
-Immorushes
-Decks with dead cards

Thumbs up:
-Pillarless SN bows(Gemfinders/RoL's/Damsels)
-Strange decks based on unusual combos
-Peggy rush
-Dis/hole
-Any deck that uses catapult/cat ability/chimera/sky blitz/solar shield/aflatoxin/nymph tears/iridium wardens.

[ralouf]

Actually I thumbs down most of the well known deck or ove used in arena decks like those guys said before.

I thumbs up every original deck, really !

And I dunno what thumbs really mean.