Readlist:
Waiting for modkill/post: antiaverage, rob77dp
v
serprex- Since I have pegged TorB and him as not w/w, TorB vouching for him is a good sign regardless of TorBs alignement. But now judging him on his own merits: He actually justified his Submachine-read surprisingly well given that the game just started (though i disagree ofc). His other reads seem fine (justificationwise at least), except sky which I dont understand at all actually. TorB certainly buddied him successfully (i mean, if that isn't love at first sight! While buddying is usually associated with scum i'm really not sure what to make of torb rn as you can see below).
Please don't kill yourself, you are technically my biggest townread.
n+
Submachine- His readlist reads genuine to me. I also gutleaned him town earlier, but can't really put my finger on why.
shockcannon - as I said earlier his first post really didnt seem like scum him, but damn he got really quiet and is trending down
not to mention that the other 2 posts are bogstandard for him.
I still townlean him for now, but upon rereading i had to realize there is nothing much there.
Masternoob - Most of his posts go in one ear and out the other. i think his questions are genuine, even if barely relevant. He's got some absurd theories too. Anyway what ultimately made me decide to townlean him is that he seems to keep up his usual posting behaviour and i would expect a first time scum to be more nervous (it would be the first time, right?). Also questioning TorBs voteswitch was a good catch.
skyironsword - claiming mafia never fails to irritate me, but the people that do that, do that whenever they feel like it. NAI. Who's Sera?
Anyway the n0 stuff is mostly reading into the hosts posts as if he were confirmed mafia and criticicing me for caring about mechanics (it's a common argument i hear on various mafiapads, but it simply doesn't apply to me, i always want to get the mechanics right (and I also got the vibe that she cares about mechanics too, just doesn't want to discuss them in public)).
Hm, come to think of it using angleshooting (like interpreting the hosts posts or monitoring peoples activity) is usually done by town looking for easier ways to solve the game. Let's give both Sub and sky a bump up.
The rest is sky calling out TorB on his lack of reasoning, which i feel is justified (i had the same questions), only backpaddling when TorB seemed to threaten to claim (which is unnecessary at this stage).
n (in no particular order)
Oa - I think everything but his readlist and wanting to kill w3 is just noise (and the latter likely a shitpost too). Readlist is about as small as you'd expect at that stage, but I need an explanation on that timpa read.
Naii - the parts that trip him up are pretty understandable, but thats NAI (heh!) i think
w3 - shitposts and massclaim and no lynch, which I really hope are also shitposts
TorB - I have questions that probably shouldn't be answered (so long as he might be town), so I won't ask. He heavily implied he's got some sunk cost fallacy with his pr, so that information is already out there
. Ofc there is also the votechange that he won't explain now. Really would want to have time to think about it, but looks like he's about to get lynched now, so I need to sort this out.
He's PR or mafia, but fortunately everyone is a PR, so that doesnt mean anything.
kdz- shitposts and discussing how to deal with inactives. I dont think I can form a read out of this.
timpa- going just by number of posts he would be outside his scumrange, but they are very short and while they aren't all strictly shitposts I don't see anything of real value (tl;dr postcount is inflated and cant be used to exclude scum)
Poll
