Elements Mafia 71 - by Submachine

[dawn to dusk]

Where is the www3 option

[Submachine]

By the way, for future games, it is worth avoiding a game breaking strategy that only requires a Graboid, a Golden Nymph, and private messaging.

The Graboid is targeted by the GN while he is a Shrieker. GN confirms the Shrieker publicly. Shrieker burrows. Everyone sends roles and info to the Graboid. The Graboid is then an unkillable, confirmed Town, who can freely speak.

[ddevans96]

By the way, for future games, it is worth avoiding a game breaking strategy that only requires a Graboid, a Golden Nymph, and private messaging.

The Graboid is targeted by the GN while he is a Shrieker. GN confirms the Shrieker publicly. Shrieker burrows. Everyone sends roles and info to the Graboid. The Graboid is then an unkillable, confirmed Town, who can freely speak.

Easy solution: never allow private messaging.

[MasterWalks]

I feel i played much better this time around. My mistakes were minimal compared to last game. My biggest mistakes this game was revealing the FireFly i caught N2 and putting a tad too much trust in Linkcat. I got pretty lucky with my N0 target and I needed to use that to my advantage, which i thought i did pretty well.

Contrary to popular opinion, I miss being able to PM. That was much harder and a lot of fun. Though, it does cause a pretty dead thread until voting.

[iancudorinmarian]

PMs was terrible.

iancudorinmarian joined.
shockcannon [»] iancudorinmarian: hey kid, I know you're mafia

Every. Single. Time.

[Submachine]

I think chat PMs should always be banned, because that cannot be supervised. However, forum PMs with a limitation might be allowed with the right ruleset. (In a way that roleclaims and overdose are not possible.)

[Mobian]

PMs allow the mafia a fun chance to manipulate the civs, just ask MW

[DoubleCapitals]

I'm vehemently against PMs of any form.

[JonathanCrazyJ]

Srsly? Forum pms are so fun.

[Mobian]

Srsly? Forum pms are so fun.

Agreed, but they do have the downside of lowering overall activity in the thread or other public venues.

[JonathanCrazyJ]

They encourage more individual intel and involvement, they make for a less sheepie game im

[Linkcat]

PMs lead to mass roleclaims, which are the sheepiest games you can have.